Constraints on the intergalactic magnetic field strength from $γ$-ray observations of GRB 221009A

Yi-Yun Huang,Cui-yuan Dai,Hai-Ming Zhang,Ruo-Yu Liu,Xiang-Yu Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/acf66a
2023-10-11
Abstract:Characteristics of the cascade gamma-ray signal resulting from very-high-energy gamma-ray sources, such as gamma-ray bursts, can be used to constrain the strength and structure of intergalactic magnetic fields (IGMF). There has been a debate on whether GRB 190114C, the first gamma-ray burst with observed TeV photons, can constrain the IGMF. Recently, LHAASO detected the brightest-of-all-time GRB 221009A, which has much larger energy in TeV band and the spectrum extends to energy above 10 TeV, providing an unprecedented opportunity to studying IGMF. We perform a Monte-Carlo simulation of the cascade process with the public ELMAG code, considering the TeV data of GRB 221009A observed by LHAASO. By comparing the resulting cascade emission with the flux limit obtained from Fermi-LAT observations, we infer a limit of $B\ge 10^{-18.5}\rm G$ for IGMF. Though this limit may not be as strong as the limit from blazars, it serves as an independent constraint on IGMF from a new class of TeV sources.
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to constrain the strength of the intergalactic magnetic field (IGMF) through high - energy gamma - ray observations of gamma - ray bursts (GRB 221009A). Specifically, the paper utilizes a large amount of photon data in the TeV energy range of GRB 221009A detected by LHAASO, combined with the observational data of Fermi - LAT, and studies the electromagnetic cascade process through Monte Carlo simulation and analysis methods, thereby deriving the lower limit of IGMF. ### Research Background The strength of the intergalactic magnetic field is of great significance for understanding the origin of the early - universe magnetic field. Very - high - energy (VHE, ≥100 GeV) transient sources, such as active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and gamma - ray bursts (GRBs), can be used to constrain IGMF. When TeV photons emitted by these sources interact with the extragalactic background light (EBL) during propagation, electron - positron pairs are produced. These pairs are deflected under the action of IGMF and radiate secondary GeV - TeV photons through inverse Compton scattering (ICS). The properties of these secondary photons when they reach the Earth, such as the energy spectrum and the time delay relative to the main emission, carry key information about IGMF. ### Research Methods 1. **Fermi - LAT Data Analysis**: - The paper first analyzes the Fermi - LAT data to set the experimental upper limit of the pair - echo intensity of GRB 221009A. - Analyzes the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of GRB 221009A and extracts the 95% confidence - level upper limits within different time intervals. 2. **Monte Carlo Simulation**: - Uses the open - code ELMAG to conduct Monte Carlo simulations and studies the electromagnetic cascade process of the main TeV photons. - Simulates three time intervals: from T0 + 4000 seconds to 3 days, from T0 + 3 days to 30 days, and from T0 + 30 days to 8 months. - Considers different IGMF strengths (from \(10^{-20}\) G to \(10^{-18.5}\) G) and three different EBL models (weak attenuation, standard case, and strong attenuation). 3. **Analytical Method**: - To verify the results of the Monte Carlo simulation, the paper also conducts analytical calculations. - The analytical method considers EBL absorption, the production and deflection of electron - positron pairs, and the inverse Compton scattering process of secondary photons. ### Main Results - **Lower Limit of IGMF**: Through Monte Carlo simulation and analytical methods, the paper obtains a conservative lower limit of IGMF as \(B\geq10^{-18.5}\) G, corresponding to a coherence length \(\lambda\leq1\) Mpc. - **Comparison with Previous Work**: This limit is more stringent than the limit derived from GRB 190114C, but may not be as strong as the limit derived from blazars. - **Systematic Error**: The main source of systematic error is the uncertainty of the EBL model. The paper adopts three different EBL models to evaluate the impact of this uncertainty. ### Conclusion GRB 221009A, as a rare high - energy event, provides a unique opportunity to study IGMF. By comprehensively using the data of Fermi - LAT and LHAASO, the paper successfully derives the lower limit of IGMF, providing new clues for understanding the origin of the early - universe magnetic field.