Topological Superconducting States and Quasiparticle Transport on Kagome Lattice

Zi-Qian Zhou,Weimin Wang,Zhi Wang,Dao-Xin Yao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.108.184506

2024-02-06

Abstract:The pairing symmetry of superconducting states is a critical topic in the realm of topological superconductivity. However, the pairing symmetry of the $A\mathrm{V_3Sb_5}$ family, wherein $A=\mathrm{K,Rb,Cs}$, remains indeterminate. To address this issue, we formulate an effective model on the kagome lattice to describe topological superconducting states featuring chiral charge density wave. Through this model, we explore the topological phase diagrams and thermal Hall conductivity under various parameters, with and without spin-orbit coupling. Our analysis reveals that the disparities in thermal Hall conductivity curves between different pairing symmetries are safeguarded by the topology resulting from the interplay of spin-orbital coupling and superconducting states. Remarkably, this theoretical prediction can potentially enable the differentiation of various superconducting pairing symmetries in materials via experimental measurements of thermal Hall conductivity curves.

Superconductivity,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine the superconducting pairing symmetry in AV3Sb5 family materials. Specifically, the author constructs an effective model on the kagome lattice to describe the topological superconducting state with chiral charge - density waves and explores the topological phase diagrams and thermal Hall conductivity in different pairing symmetry states. The main goal of the research is to distinguish different superconducting pairing symmetry states through experimental measurement of the thermal Hall conductivity curve.

### Background and Problems
1. **Background**:
- AV3Sb5 family materials (where A = K, Rb, Cs) are the first examples of quasi - two - dimensional kagome superconductors.
- These materials exhibit charge - density - wave (CDW) order and superconducting (SC) properties.
- Determining the superconducting pairing symmetry in these materials is a highly controversial issue, and no clear conclusion has been found so far.

2. **Existing Problems**:
- Most studies support the traditional s - wave pairing, but some experiments have observed non - traditional behaviors.
- For example, the U - shaped differential conductance and the existence of gapless states support s - wave pairing, while the unsplit zero - bias conductance peak implies the possible existence of p - wave pairing.
- The experimental results of thermal conductivity are similar to those of the d - wave superconductor Tl - 2201, also suggesting possible d - wave pairing.

### Research Methods
1. **Model Construction**:
- A two - dimensional kagome lattice effective model including chiral charge - density wave (CDW), spin - orbit coupling (SOC) and superconducting (SC) was constructed.
- The model is divided into four parts: the nearest - neighbor tight - binding part, the CDW part, the SOC part and the SC part.

2. **Theoretical Analysis**:
- The Berry curvature, Chern number and thermal Hall conductivity were calculated.
- The topological phase diagrams and thermal Hall conductivity curves in different pairing symmetries (s - wave, d + id - wave, d - id - wave) were explored.

### Main Findings
1. **Topological Phase Diagrams**:
- In the absence of spin - orbit coupling, the Chern number of s - wave pairing is 2, the Chern number of d + id - wave pairing is 4, and the Chern number of d - id - wave pairing is 0.
- When the chemical potential μ is in the range of (0, 0.1], the system becomes a metal, and the Chern numbers of different pairing symmetries are different.

2. **Thermal Hall Conductivity**:
- By calculating the Berry curvature of the highest occupied band, the thermal Hall conductivity curves in different pairing symmetry states were obtained.
- The thermal Hall conductivity of s - wave pairing is close to zero at low temperatures and gradually increases with temperature.
- The thermal Hall conductivity of d + id - wave pairing increases rapidly at low temperatures.
- The thermal Hall conductivity of d - id - wave pairing is negative at low temperatures and gradually decreases with temperature.

### Conclusion
By experimentally measuring the thermal Hall conductivity curve, different superconducting pairing symmetry states in AV3Sb5 family materials can be effectively distinguished. This method provides a new way to understand the superconducting properties of these materials.