Zhen Qin,Rolf Jagerman,Rama Pasumarthi,Honglei Zhuang,He Zhang,Aijun Bai,Kai Hui,Le Yan,Xuanhui Wang
Abstract:The distillation of ranking models has become an important topic in both academia and industry. In recent years, several advanced methods have been proposed to tackle this problem, often leveraging ranking information from teacher rankers that is absent in traditional classification settings. To date, there is no well-established consensus on how to evaluate this class of models. Moreover, inconsistent benchmarking on a wide range of tasks and datasets make it difficult to assess or invigorate advances in this field. This paper first examines representative prior arts on ranking distillation, and raises three questions to be answered around methodology and reproducibility. To that end, we propose a systematic and unified benchmark, Ranking Distillation Suite (RD-Suite), which is a suite of tasks with 4 large real-world datasets, encompassing two major modalities (textual and numeric) and two applications (standard distillation and distillation transfer). RD-Suite consists of benchmark results that challenge some of the common wisdom in the field, and the release of datasets with teacher scores and evaluation scripts for future research. RD-Suite paves the way towards better understanding of ranking distillation, facilities more research in this direction, and presents new challenges.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the lack of uniformity in the evaluation and experimental settings of current Ranking Distillation methods, which makes it difficult to compare different methods. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:
1. **Lack of uniform evaluation criteria**: Currently, there is no widely - accepted standard for evaluating the effectiveness of ranking distillation methods. Different studies use different tasks, datasets, and model configurations, which makes it difficult to compare methods.
2. **Methodology and reproducibility issues**: Existing ranking distillation methods have some assumptions in methodology, which may limit the performance of the methods. In addition, due to the different ways of handling the score values of teacher models, it is difficult to reproduce the experimental results.
3. **Diversity of datasets and tasks**: Existing research often focuses on specific datasets and tasks, lacking comprehensive coverage of different modalities (text and numerical) and application scenarios (standard distillation and distillation transfer).
To solve these problems, the paper proposes a systematic benchmarking suite - Ranking Distillation Suite (RD - Suite), aiming to provide a unified evaluation framework that covers multiple datasets, modalities, and methods, thereby promoting further research and development in the field of ranking distillation.
### Specific objectives
1. **Establish uniform evaluation criteria**: By designing a benchmarking suite that includes multiple tasks and datasets, ensure that different methods are evaluated under the same conditions, improving the comparability and reliability of the results.
2. **Challenge the assumptions of existing methods**: By systematically analyzing the assumptions and limitations of existing methods, raise new research questions and promote innovation in the field.
3. **Provide public resources**: Release datasets and evaluation scripts to facilitate researchers to reproduce experimental results and promote the transparency and reproducibility of research.
### Main contributions
1. **Systematic ranking distillation benchmarking suite**: Covers multiple datasets, modalities, and methods, ensuring comprehensiveness and diversity of evaluation.
2. **Raise key questions**: Focusing on methodology and reproducibility, raise three key questions, challenge the assumptions of existing methods, and provide new research directions.
3. **Publish public datasets and evaluation scripts**: Provide easily accessible datasets and evaluation tools to promote future research.
### Conclusion
By proposing RD - Suite, the paper provides an important foundation for research in the field of ranking distillation, not only solving the problem of non - uniform evaluation criteria, but also opening new doors for future innovative research.