The Creative Frontier of Generative AI: Managing the Novelty-Usefulness Tradeoff

Anirban Mukherjee,Hannah Chang

2023-06-06

Abstract:In this paper, drawing inspiration from the human creativity literature, we explore the optimal balance between novelty and usefulness in generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems. We posit that overemphasizing either aspect can lead to limitations such as hallucinations and memorization. Hallucinations, characterized by AI responses containing random inaccuracies or falsehoods, emerge when models prioritize novelty over usefulness. Memorization, where AI models reproduce content from their training data, results from an excessive focus on usefulness, potentially limiting creativity. To address these challenges, we propose a framework that includes domain-specific analysis, data and transfer learning, user preferences and customization, custom evaluation metrics, and collaboration mechanisms. Our approach aims to generate content that is both novel and useful within specific domains, while considering the unique requirements of various contexts.

Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the optimal balance between novelty and usefulness in generative artificial intelligence (AI) systems. The author points out that over - emphasizing either aspect may lead to limitations, such as the occurrence of hallucinations or memorization in the generated content. Specifically:

- **Hallucinations**: When the model over - pursues novelty, it may produce responses containing randomly inaccurate or false information. Although these contents are novel, they lack practical value.
- **Memorization**: When the model over - pursues usefulness, it may repeat the content in the training data, resulting in the generated content lacking innovation.

To address these challenges, the paper proposes a framework, including the following aspects:

1. **Domain - specific analysis**: By in - depth study of the creativity literature in relevant fields and consulting domain experts, determine the ideal balance point between novelty and usefulness to ensure that the generated content is both innovative and in line with the characteristics of the field.
2. **Domain - specific data and transfer learning**: Use domain - specific data sets for training and adopt transfer learning techniques to enable AI models to better adapt to the target domain and generate more relevant and novel content.
3. **User preferences and customization**: Introduce a user interface or feedback mechanism to allow users to express their preferences in terms of novelty and usefulness, thereby personalizing the adjustment of AI - generated content.
4. **Custom evaluation metrics**: Develop evaluation metrics that combine novelty and usefulness to ensure that the generated content strikes a balance between originality and applicability.
5. **Collaboration mechanisms**: Implement collaborative mechanisms such as ensemble learning or multi - agent systems, and optimize the balance between novelty and usefulness through the collective wisdom of multiple AI models.

The goal of the paper is to build an AI system that can generate both innovative and useful content through the above methods, while considering the unique requirements of different application scenarios. This not only helps to improve the performance of AI systems, but also addresses ethical concerns and bias issues, ensuring that AI - generated content is both accurate and fair.