Fate of bubble clusters rising in a quiescent liquid

Tian Ma,Hendrik Hessenkemper,Dirk Luca,Andrew D. Bragg

2023-06-07

Abstract:We use experiments to study the evolution of bubble clusters in a swarm of freely rising, deformable bubbles. A new machine learning-aided algorithm allows us to identify and track bubbles in clusters and measure the cluster lifetimes. The results indicate that contamination in the carrier liquid can enhance the formation of bubble clusters and prolong the cluster lifetimes. The mean bubble rise velocities conditioned on the bubble cluster size are also explored, and we find a positive correlation between the cluster size and the rise speed of the bubbles in the cluster, with clustered bubbles rising up to $20\%$ faster than unclustered bubbles.

Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the evolution and characteristics of bubble clusters formed when a group of bubbles rise in a stationary liquid. Specifically, the researchers studied the formation, duration of bubble clusters in freely - rising deformed bubble groups and the relationship between bubble rising speed and bubble cluster size through experimental methods. In addition, the paper also explored how contaminants in the liquid affect the formation and behavior of these bubble clusters.

### Main research questions:
1. **Probability of bubble cluster formation**: What is the probability of forming a cluster containing \( N_b \) bubbles under different conditions?
2. **Lifetime of bubble clusters**: Analyze the average lifetime of bubble clusters and explore its relationship with the size of bubble clusters and the degree of liquid contamination.
3. **Rising speed of bubble clusters**: Explore how the rising speed of bubble clusters changes with the size of bubble clusters and compare it with the rising speed of a single bubble.

### Research background:
- The rise of bubbles in a liquid is a natural phenomenon, which is widely present in nature, daily life and technological applications.
- In a freely - rising bubble group, bubbles tend to be unevenly distributed and spontaneously form clusters.
- Large - sized bubbles will generate turbulence (called bubble - induced turbulence, BIT) during the rising process, which will affect the behavior of bubble clusters.
- Early numerical simulations assumed that bubbles were spherical and considered the potential flow situation, but subsequent experiments and more realistic numerical simulations found that the most common bubble clusters are composed of two bubbles, and these two bubbles can have different relative positions.

### Research methods:
- **Experimental device**: Use a rectangular bubble column to inject air bubbles through multiple nozzles at the bottom.
- **Bubble detection and tracking**: Use high - resolution planar shadow images and machine - learning algorithms to detect and track bubble clusters.
- **Data processing**: Achieve quasi - three - dimensional tracking of bubbles through graph - structured data and message - passing networks (MPN).

### Main findings:
1. **Probability of bubble cluster formation**: 2 - bubble clusters are the most common, but 3 - bubble and 4 - bubble clusters also appear frequently. The presence of contaminants will increase the probability of the formation of larger bubble clusters.
2. **Lifetime of bubble clusters**: The average lifetime of bubble clusters is approximately \( \frac{d_b}{U_b} \), where \( d_b \) is the bubble diameter and \( U_b \) is the average vertical sliding speed of the bubble relative to the liquid. Larger bubble clusters are not only rarer but also more unstable. An increase in contaminants will prolong the lifetime of bubble clusters.
3. **Rising speed of bubble clusters**: The rising speed of bubble clusters is positively correlated with the size of bubble clusters, and the rising speed of bubbles in the cluster is approximately 20% faster than that of a single bubble. This enhancement is mainly due to the shielding effect of the leading bubble on the trailing bubble, which reduces the drag.

### Conclusions:
- 2 - bubble clusters are the most common type of bubble clusters, but 3 - bubble and 4 - bubble clusters also appear frequently.
- Contaminants will promote the formation of larger bubble clusters and prolong their lifetimes.
- The rising speed of bubble clusters is faster than that of a single bubble, which is mainly due to the shielding effect between bubbles reducing the drag.

Through these studies, the authors provide important experimental data and theoretical support for understanding the behavior of bubble groups in stationary liquids.