Abstract:The usual approach to Kaluza-Klein considers a spacetime of the form $M_4 \times K$ and identifies the isometry group of the internal vacuum metric, $g_K^0$, with the gauge group in four dimensions. In these notes we discuss a variant approach where part of the gauge group does not come from full isometries of $g_K^0$, but instead comes from weaker internal symmetries that only preserve the Einstein-Hilbert action on $K$. Then the weaker symmetries are spontaneously broken by the choice of vacuum metric and generate massive gauge bosons within the Kaluza-Klein framework, with no need to introduce ad hoc Higgs fields. Using the language of Riemannian submersions, the classical mass of a gauge boson is calculated in terms of the Lie derivatives of $g_K^0$. These massive bosons can be arbitrarily light and seem able to evade the standard no-go arguments against chiral fermionic interactions in Kaluza-Klein. As a second main theme, we also question the traditional assumption of a Kaluza-Klein vacuum represented by a product Einstein metric. This should not be true when that metric is unstable. In fact, we argue that the unravelling of the Einstein metric along certain instabilities is a desirable feature of the model, since it generates inflation and allows some metric components to change length scale. In the case of the Lie group $K = SU(3)$, the unravelling of the bi-invariant metric along an unstable perturbation also breaks the isometry group from $( SU(3) \times SU(3)) / Z_3$ down to $( SU(3) \times SU(2) \times U(1) )/ Z_6$, the gauge group of the Standard Model. We briefly discuss possible ways to stabilize the internal metric after that first symmetry breaking and produce an electroweak symmetry breaking at a different mass scale.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the internal symmetry and mass - generation mechanism in the Kaluza - Klein theory. Specifically, the paper explores the following two main aspects:
1. **Extension of internal symmetry**:
- The paper proposes a new method. That is, the partial gauge group does not only come from the complete isometric transformation of the internal vacuum metric \( g_0^K \), but from weaker internal symmetries which only keep the Einstein - Hilbert action on \( K \) invariant. This weak symmetry is spontaneously broken when choosing the vacuum metric, thus generating massive gauge bosons within the Kaluza - Klein framework without introducing an additional Higgs field.
- By using the language of Riemannian submersion, the paper calculates the classical masses of the gauge bosons, which are related to the Lie derivative of \( g_0^K \). These massive bosons can be very light and seem to be able to evade the standard arguments against chiral fermion interactions in Kaluza - Klein.
2. **Instability of the Einstein metric**:
- The paper questions the assumption in the traditional Kaluza - Klein theory that the vacuum metric is represented as a product Einstein metric. When this metric is unstable, this assumption may not hold.
- The paper believes that the expansion of the Einstein metric along certain instabilities is a desirable feature of a model because it can generate inflation and allow some metric components to change scale. For example, in the case of \( K = SU(3) \), expanding the bi - invariant metric along unstable perturbations will break the symmetry group from \( (SU(3)\times SU(3))/Z_3 \) to \( (SU(3)\times SU(2)\times U(1))/Z_6 \), that is, the gauge group of the standard model.
- The paper also discusses how to stabilize the internal metric after the first symmetry breaking and produce electro - weak symmetry breaking at different mass scales.
### Formula analysis
1. **Mass formula of gauge bosons**:
\[
\text{Mass}(A_a^\mu)^2 \propto \frac{\int_K \langle L_e g_0^K, L_e g_0^K \rangle \, \text{vol}_{g_0^K}}{2 \int_K g_0^K(e, e) \, \text{vol}_{g_0^K}}
\]
Here, \( g_0^K \) is the vacuum metric of the internal space, and \( L_e g_0^K \) is the Lie derivative of \( g_0^K \) with respect to the vector field \( e \).
2. **Decomposition of high - dimensional scalar curvature**:
\[
R_{g_P} = R_{g_M} + R_{g_K} - |F|^2 - |S|^2 - |N|^2 - 2\delta N
\]
where \( R_{g_M} \) and \( R_{g_K} \) are the scalar curvatures of the four - dimensional space - time metric \( g_M \) and the internal metric \( g_K \) respectively, \( |F|^2 \) is the part that generates the Yang - Mills term, and \( |S|^2 \) and \( |N|^2 \) are the squared norms of the second fundamental form and the mean curvature vector of the fiber respectively.
3. **Second fundamental form of the fiber**:
\[
|S|^2 = \frac{1}{4} g_{\mu\nu}^M \langle L_{X_\mu} g_P, L_{X_\nu} g_P \rangle + \frac{1}{2} g_{\mu\nu}^M A_\mu^a \langle L_{e_a} g_P, L_{X_\nu} g_P \rangle + \frac{1}{4} g_{\mu\nu}^M A_\mu^a A_\nu^b \langle L_{e_a} g_P, L_{e_b} g_P \rangle
\]