Abstract:Coleman's theorem states that continuous internal symmetries cannot be spontaneously broken in two-dimensional quantum field theories (QFTs). In this work we consider surface (i.e. two-dimensional) defects in $d$-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) invariant under a continuous internal symmetry group $G$. We study under which conditions it is possible for a surface defect to break spontaneously a continuous internal symmetry. We find that spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) is impossible under reasonable assumptions on the defect Renormalization Group (RG) flow. Counterexamples are possible only for exotic RG flows, that do not terminate at a fixed-point. We discuss an example of this kind. We also illustrate our no-go result with an effective field theory analysis of generic defect RG flows. We find a generic weakly coupled defect universality class (with no SSB), where correlation functions decay logarithmically. Our analysis generalizes the recent discovery by Metlitski of the extraordinary-log boundary universality class in the $O(N)$ model.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether two - dimensional defects (surface defects) can spontaneously break continuous internal symmetry in high - dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs). Specifically, the authors explored under which conditions a surface defect can spontaneously break continuous internal symmetry and studied the possibility of this spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB).
### Background and Motivation of the Paper
1. **Coleman Theorem**: In ordinary two - dimensional quantum field theories (QFTs), the Coleman theorem states that continuous internal symmetry cannot be spontaneously broken. This theorem is a corollary based on the Goldstone theorem, that is, spontaneous symmetry breaking will lead to the existence of massless particles (Goldstone bosons), and the propagators of these massless particles exhibit a logarithmic form in two - dimensional space, causing the correlation functions to grow at large distances, thus making the ordered phase unstable.
2. **Surface Defects**: In high - dimensional conformal field theories, the existence of surface defects (i.e., two - dimensional defects) may change this conclusion. Surface defects can be regarded as a non - local operator acting on the vacuum state of the theory, or as modifying the Hamiltonian (or action) of the system in certain regions. These defects usually become scale - invariant at long distances and even enhance to full conformal invariance in many cases.
### Main Research Contents
1. **Conditions for Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking**: The authors studied under which conditions surface defects can spontaneously break continuous internal symmetry. They found that, under reasonable assumptions, surface defects cannot spontaneously break continuous internal symmetry. Only in some singular renormalization group (RG) flows can this spontaneous symmetry breaking possibly occur, but these singular RG flows do not terminate at fixed points.
2. **Counterexample**: The author provided a specific example, showing that in some special cases, spontaneous symmetry breaking can indeed occur. This example involves the O(N)/O(N - 1) nonlinear σ - model coupled to a two - dimensional surface in the free scalar field theory in 4 < d < 6 dimensions. When the bulk fields are integrated out, the model is similar to the two - dimensional long - range O(N) model, and at this time the RG flow is of the runaway type, rather than terminating at a fixed point.
3. **Weak - Coupling Defect Universality Class**: The author also discovered a general weak - coupling defect universality class in which there is no spontaneous symmetry breaking, but the correlation functions decay logarithmically with distance. This behavior can be described by a marginally - irrelevant interaction term, similar to the "extraordinary - logarithmic" boundary universality class recently discovered in the three - dimensional O(N) model.
### Conclusions
- **Main Results**: The author argued that in unitary theories, if the defect quantum field theory (DQFT) flows to a scale - invariant fixed point at energies below the spontaneous symmetry breaking scale, then spontaneous symmetry breaking cannot occur. This conclusion is supported by non - perturbative analysis and effective field theory (EFT) analysis.
- **Runaway - type RG Flows**: A specific example was provided, showing that in some special cases, spontaneous symmetry breaking can indeed occur, but the RG flows in these cases are of the runaway type, rather than terminating at a fixed point.
- **Logarithmically Decaying Correlation Functions**: A general weak - coupling defect universality class was discovered, in which the correlation functions decay logarithmically with distance, which provides a new perspective for understanding the properties of surface defects.
### Formula Examples
- **Two - point Function of Goldstone Modes**:
\[
\langle J_a^\mu(x)O_A(0)\rangle=\int\frac{d^2p}{(2\pi)^2}e^{-ipx}H^\mu(p)
\]
where
\[
H^\mu(p)=-i\delta_{av}\frac{p^\mu}{p^2 + i\epsilon}\mu_\nu p^\nu f(p^2)
\]
- **Spectral Density**:
\[
H^\mu(p)=\int_0^\infty dm^2\frac{p^\mu\rho_P(m^2)+\epsilon^{\mu\nu}p_\nu\rho_A(m^2)}{p^2 + m^2}
\]
- **Logarithmically Decaying Correlation Functions**:
\[