Is Silent eHMI Enough? A Passenger-Centric Study on Effective eHMI for Autonomous Personal Mobility Vehicles in the Field

Hailong Liu,Yang Li,Zhe Zeng,Hao Cheng,Chen Peng,Takahiro Wada
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10447318.2024.2306426
2023-10-16
Abstract:Autonomous Personal Mobility Vehicle (APMV) is a miniaturized autonomous vehicle designed to provide short-distance mobility to everyone in pedestrian-rich environments. By the characteristic of the open design, passengers on the APMV are exposed to the communication between the eHMI deployed on APMVs and pedestrians. Therefore, to ensure an optimal passenger experience, eHMI designs for APMVs must consider the potential impact of APMV-pedestrian communications on passengers' subjective feelings. To this end, this study discussed three external human-machine interface (eHMI) designs, i.e., 1) graphical user interface (GUI)-based eHMI with text message (eHMI-T), 2) multimodal user interface (MUI)-based eHMI with neutral voice (eHMI-NV), and 3) MUI-based eHMI with affective voice (eHMI-AV), from the perspective of APMV passengers in the communication between APMV and pedestrians. In the riding field experiment (N=24), we found that eHMI-T may be less suitable for APMVs. This conclusion was drawn based on passengers' feedback, as they expressed an awkward feeling during the "silent time" when the eHMI-T provided information only to pedestrians but not to passengers. Additionally, these two MUI-based eHMIs with voice cues had their own advantages, i.e., eHMI-NV has an advantage in pragmatic quality, while eHMI-AV has an advantage in hedonic quality. The study also highlights the necessity of considering passengers' personalities when desig
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is: how to design effective external human-machine interfaces (eHMI) for autonomous personal mobility vehicles (APMV) when interacting with pedestrians in pedestrian-dense shared spaces to ensure optimal passenger experience. Specifically, the study explores three different eHMI design schemes, including a text-based eHMI (eHMI-T) based on a graphical user interface (GUI), a neutral voice eHMI (eHMI-NV) based on a multimodal user interface (MUI), and an MUI eHMI with emotional voice (eHMI-AV). The study found through field experiments that relying solely on a GUI-based eHMI (eHMI-T) may not be suitable for APMV, as passengers may feel awkward during "silent times." Additionally, the two MUI eHMIs with voice prompts each have their advantages: eHMI-NV performs better in terms of pragmatic quality, while eHMI-AV excels in hedonic quality. Finally, the study emphasizes the importance of considering passenger personality in the design of eHMI for APMV to enhance their experience.