Macroeconomic Effects of Inflation Targeting: A Survey of the Empirical Literature

Goran Petrevski
2023-05-27
Abstract:This paper surveys the empirical literature of inflation targeting. The main findings from our review are the following: there is robust empirical evidence that larger and more developed countries are more likely to adopt the IT regime; the introduction of this regime is conditional on previous disinflation, greater exchange rate flexibility, central bank independence, and higher level of financial development; the empirical evidence has failed to provide convincing evidence that IT itself may serve as an effective tool for stabilizing inflation expectations and for reducing inflation persistence; the empirical research focused on advanced economies has failed to provide convincing evidence on the beneficial effects of IT on inflation performance, while there is some evidence that the gains from the IT regime may have been more prevalent in the emerging market economies; there is not convincing evidence that IT is associated with either higher output growth or lower output variability; the empirical research suggests that IT may have differential effects on exchange-rate volatility in advanced economies versus EMEs; although the empirical evidence on the impact of IT on fiscal policy is quite limited, it supports the idea that IT indeed improves fiscal discipline; the empirical support to the proposition that IT is associated with lower disinflation costs seems to be rather weak. Therefore, the accumulated empirical literature implies that IT does not produce superior macroeconomic benefits in comparison with the alternative monetary strategies or, at most, they are quite modest.
General Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of the effects and implementation conditions of Inflation Targeting (IT) in the macroeconomy through a literature review. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Determinants of adopting Inflation Targeting**: The study examines which institutional, macroeconomic, and technical factors influence a country's decision to adopt Inflation Targeting. For example, research has found that larger, more developed countries are more likely to adopt Inflation Targeting; additionally, the introduction of this regime typically requires prior deflation, greater exchange rate flexibility, central bank independence, and a higher level of financial development. 2. **Impact of Inflation Targeting on macroeconomic performance**: The paper explores the impact of Inflation Targeting on macroeconomic performance (such as inflation expectations, inflation persistence, average inflation rate, inflation volatility, output growth rate, output volatility, interest rates, exchange rates, and fiscal outcomes). The research findings indicate that in developed countries, Inflation Targeting has not provided convincing evidence that it effectively stabilizes inflation expectations or reduces inflation persistence; whereas in emerging market countries, Inflation Targeting may bring more benefits. 3. **Anti-inflation costs of Inflation Targeting**: The paper assesses whether Inflation Targeting is associated with lower anti-inflation costs (i.e., the so-called sacrifice ratio). It points out that while there is some evidence suggesting that Inflation Targeting helps improve fiscal discipline, the relationship between it and lower anti-inflation costs is not clear. Overall, although Inflation Targeting is becoming increasingly popular worldwide, existing empirical literature suggests that it is not significantly superior to other monetary policy strategies, or at most, only slightly better. Through a comprehensive analysis of these issues, the paper aims to fill the gaps in the existing review literature and provide references for policymakers.