Societal feedback induces complex and chaotic dynamics in endemic infectious diseases

Joel Wagner,Simon Bauer,Sebastian Contreras,Luk Fleddermann,Ulrich Parlitz,Viola Priesemann

2023-05-19

Abstract:Classically, endemic diseases are expected to display relatively stable, predictable infection dynamics. Indeed, diseases like influenza show yearly recurring infection waves that can be anticipated accurately enough to develop and distribute new vaccines. In contrast, newly-emerging diseases may cause more complex, unpredictable dynamics, like COVID-19 has demonstrated. Here we show that complex infection dynamics can also occur in the endemic state of seasonal diseases when including human behaviour. We implement human behaviour as a feedback between incidence and disease mitigation and study the system as an epidemiological oscillator driven by seasonality. When behaviour and seasonality have a comparable impact, we find a rich structure in parameter and state space with Arnold tongues, co-existing attractors, and chaos. Moreover, we demonstrate that if a disease requires active mitigation, balancing costs of mitigation and infections can lead societies right into this complex regime. We observe indications of this when comparing past COVID-19 and influenza data to model simulations. Our results challenge the intuition that endemicity implies predictability and seasonal waves, and show that complex dynamics can dominate even in the endemic phase.

Physics and Society,Dynamical Systems,Populations and Evolution

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper explores the possibility that seasonal epidemics may exhibit complex and chaotic dynamic characteristics when considering human behavior feedback. Specifically, the study focuses on the following core issues:

1. **Introducing the impact of human behavior**: The paper proposes incorporating human behavior feedback (such as measures to reduce contact and isolation to lower the likelihood of disease transmission) into infectious disease models to study how these behaviors affect the patterns of disease spread.

2. **Emergence of complex dynamics**: By extending the traditional SIRS model (a classic infectious disease model) to include seasonal factors and human behavior feedback mechanisms (referred to as the SIRSsm model), the authors find that even when a seasonal disease reaches a stable "endemic" state, complex infection dynamics can still occur, including period locking, multistability, and chaotic phenomena.

3. **Interaction between seasonality and mitigation measures**: When the effects of seasonality and human behavior mitigation measures are comparable or interact, the system can exhibit rich structures in the parameter space, such as Arnold tongue diagrams, coexisting attractors, and chaotic dynamics.

4. **Overlap of cost optimization and complex dynamics**: Furthermore, the study explores the possibility that society may fall into regions of complex dynamics when balancing the costs of mitigation measures and infection costs. In other words, when considering the total cost to society of infections and mitigation measures, the cost-optimal mitigation strategy may lead to unpredictable disease dynamics.

In summary, this paper challenges the traditional view that endemic diseases are always predictable and reveals that complex dynamics can dominate even in the endemic phase of a disease. This finding is significant for understanding the development trends of epidemics and designing control strategies.