Temperature inhomogeneities cause the abundance discrepancy in H II regions

J. Eduardo Méndez-Delgado,César Esteban,Jorge García-Rojas,Kathryn Kreckel,Manuel Peimbert

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-05956-2

2023-05-19

Abstract:HII regions, ionized nebulae where massive star formation has taken place, exhibit a wealth of emission lines that are the fundamental basis for estimating the chemical composition of the Universe. For more than 80 years, a discrepancy of at least a factor of two between heavy-element abundances derived with collisional excited lines (CELs) and the weaker recombination lines (RLs) has thrown our absolute abundance determinations into doubt. Heavy elements regulate the cooling of the interstellar gas, being essential to the understanding of several phenomena such as nucleosynthesis, star formation and chemical evolution. In this work, we use the best available deep optical spectra of ionized nebulae to analyze the cause of this abundance discrepancy problem. We find for the first time general observational evidence in favor of the temperature inhomogeneities within the gas, quantified by t2. The temperature inhomogeneities inside H II regions are affecting only the gas of high ionization degree and producing the abundance discrepancy problem. This work implies that the metallicity determinations based on CELs must be revised, as they can be severely underestimated, especially in the regions of lower metallicity, such as the JWST high-z galaxies. We present methods to estimate these corrections, which will be critical for robust interpretations of the chemical composition of the Universe over cosmic time.

Astrophysics of Galaxies,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the difference in heavy - element abundances in H II regions (ionized nebulae) due to temperature inhomogeneities. Specifically, there is at least a two - fold difference between the heavy - element abundances determined by collision - excited lines (CELs) and recombination lines (RLs), and this difference has puzzled scientists for more than 80 years.

### Problem Background
- **H II Regions**: These are the regions where massive stars are formed and contain abundant emission lines, which are the basis for estimating the chemical composition of the universe.
- **Abundance Difference**: Since the 1940s, studies have found that there are significant differences in the heavy - element abundances determined by collision - excited lines (CELs) and recombination lines (RLs), with the former usually underestimating the abundances.

### Research Objectives
The main objectives of the paper are:
1. **Explain the Cause of the Abundance Difference**: By analyzing the best available deep optical spectral data, explore whether temperature inhomogeneities are the root cause of this problem.
2. **Quantify Temperature Inhomogeneities**: Use the parameter \(t^2\) to quantify temperature inhomogeneities and evaluate their impact on gases with different degrees of ionization.
3. **Provide a Correction Method**: Propose a correction method based on temperature inhomogeneities to more accurately estimate the chemical composition of H II regions.

### Key Findings
- **Impact of Temperature Inhomogeneities**: The study found that temperature inhomogeneities mainly affect gases with a high degree of ionization, while the temperature in the low - ionization region is relatively uniform.
- **Abundance Difference Factor (ADF)**: By comparing the O\(^{2+}\)/H\(^+\) ratio obtained from the O II V1 recombination line and the [O III] λ5007 collision - excited line, the abundance difference factor (ADF) was calculated, and it was found that the ADF is closely related to temperature inhomogeneities.
- **Linear Correlation**: The paper shows the linear relationship between the temperature inhomogeneity parameter \(t^2(O^{2+})\) and the temperature difference \(\Delta T_e=T_e([O III]\lambda4363 /\lambda5007)-T_e([N II]\lambda5755 /\lambda6584)\):

\[t^2(O^{2+})=(2.90\pm0.21)\times 10^{-5}\Delta T_e+(4.68\pm0.18)\times 10^{-2}\, \text{(K)}\]

### Conclusions and Implications
- **Re - evaluate Metallicity**: Based on the existence of temperature inhomogeneities, the metallicity estimated by CELs may be severely underestimated, especially in low - metallicity regions.
- **Impact on Chemical Evolution Studies**: This finding has far - reaching significance for the study of chemical evolution in the Milky Way and extragalactic galaxies, especially when using JWST to observe high - redshift galaxies.

In conclusion, this paper provides a new perspective and solution to the long - standing abundance difference problem through in - depth analysis of temperature inhomogeneities.