How does agency impact human-AI collaborative design space exploration? A case study on ship design with deep generative models

Shahroz Khan,Panagiotis Kaklis,Kosa Goucher-Lambert

2023-05-17

Abstract:Typical parametric approaches restrict the exploration of diverse designs by generating variations based on a baseline design. In contrast, generative models provide a solution by leveraging existing designs to create compact yet diverse generative design spaces (GDSs). However, the effectiveness of current exploration methods in complex GDSs, especially in ship hull design, remains unclear. To that end, we first construct a GDS using a generative adversarial network, trained on 52,591 designs of various ship types. Next, we constructed three modes of exploration, random (REM), semi-automated (SAEM) and automated (AEM), with varying levels of user involvement to explore GDS for novel and optimised designs. In REM, users manually explore the GDS based on intuition. In SAEM, both the users and optimiser drive the exploration. The optimiser focuses on exploring a diverse set of optimised designs, while the user directs the exploration towards their design preference. AEM uses an optimiser to search for the global optimum based on design performance. Our results revealed that REM generates the most diverse designs, followed by SAEM and AEM. However, the SAEM and AEM produce better-performing designs. Specifically, SAEM is the most effective in exploring designs with a high trade-off between novelty and performance. In conclusion, our study highlights the need for innovative exploration approaches to fully harness the potential of GDS in design optimisation.

Machine Learning

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to effectively use generative models to generate diverse and optimized design schemes in the complex artificial - intelligence - assisted design space exploration, especially in the specific application field of ship design. Traditional parametric methods are limited by the baseline design when generating design variants, and it is difficult to support rich design exploration, resulting in a lack of novel design solutions. Generative models, such as generative adversarial networks (GANs), can learn from existing designs and create compact yet diverse generative design spaces (GDSs). However, the effectiveness of current exploration methods in complex GDSs, especially in ship hull design applications, remains unclear. Therefore, this paper constructs a GAN - based GDS and develops three design exploration modes with different degrees of autonomy - the random exploration mode (REM), the semi - automated exploration mode (SAEM), and the automated exploration mode (AEM) - to study the effects of these modes in generating diverse, novel, and better - performing design schemes. The study also explores designers' views on different exploration modes and how these modes affect their ability to generate novel design solutions.