Abstract:This paper examines the incentives for efficient pricing mechanism in markets with non-convexities. The wholesale electricity market is a prominent example. Ideally, an efficient pricing mechanism produces market signals that reflect costs and scarcities, incents price-taking behavior and yields sufficient revenues to attract new investment. However, under non-convex conditions, there is no assurance that these goals can be fully achieved, and market equilibrium may not even exist. Previous studies on markets with convexities have been focusing on the revenue sufficiency problem. Positive results on incentives are relatively scarce. This paper is intended to fill the gap. With non-convexities, quasi-equilibrium entails solving separately a non-convex allocation model and a convexified pricing model with solution support payments in settlement. We consider three convex relaxation methods, including Lagrangian dualization, convex-hull relaxation and integer relaxation (Integer relaxation refers to a convex relaxation of mixed integer programing problem in which the integer variables are linearized). We show that quasi-equilibrium pricing is dominant strategy incentive compatible in the limit and the total side payment divided by the total surplus approaches zero when the market size (e.g., measured by the number of consumers) increases to infinity. In essence, the quasi-equilibrium pricing mechanism extends efficient pricing principles from a convex market environment to one that is non-convex in ways that preserve economic efficiency, incentive compatibility and revenue sufficiency. These results are illustrated in the context of wholesale electricity markets. Since 2014, price formation issues have been vigorously debated in the U.S. including FERC's conferences and proceedings with comments from academics, policy and business communities across ISO/RTO regions. Convex-hull pricing is generally considered an ideal solution but it remains computationally prohibitive. In this paper, we identify conditions under which the integer relaxation method can produce close and sometimes even exact approximations to convex-hull pricing. In April 2019, FERC authorized the use of integer relaxation as a just and reasonable pricing method for fast-start units in PJM's energy markets.

Yquilibrium: A Theory for (Non-) Convex Economies

The Economy's Potential: Duality and Equilibrium

Solving equilibrium problems in economies with financial markets, home production, and retention

On Equilibrium Pricing As Convex Optimization

Equilibrium modeling and solution approaches inspired by nonconvex bilevel programming

Walrasian Equilibrium in Large, Quasilinear Markets

Relaxed Large Economies with Infinite-Dimensional Commodity Spaces: The Existence of Walrasian Equilibria

Counteracting Inequality in Markets via Convex Pricing

Incentives for efficient pricing mechanism in markets with non-convexities

General Equilibrium in a Heterogeneous-Agent Incomplete-Market Economy with Many Consumption Goods and a Risk-Free Bond

First-Order Methods for Large-Scale Market Equilibrium Computation

Reaching an equilibrium of prices and holdings of goods through direct buying and selling

Existence of Equilibrium in Abstract Economies with Discontinuous Payoffs and Noncompact Choice Spaces

Approximating Competitive Equilibrium by Nash Welfare

M Equilibrium: A theory of beliefs and choices in games

A general theory of equilibrium behavior

The virtues and vices of equilibrium and the future of financial economics

Combinatorial Walrasian Equilibrium

A Free and Fair Economy: A Game of Justice and Inclusion

Quasi-Perfect Stackelberg Equilibrium

Compromise, Don't Optimize: Generalizing Perfect Bayesian Equilibrium to Allow for Ambiguity