Experimental data about the evacuation of preschool children from nursery schools -- Part I: Pre-movement behaviour

Hana Najmanová,Enrico Ronchi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.firesaf.2023.103798
2023-05-03
Abstract:This article presents experimental data sets and information about the pre-movement behaviour and specific evacuation conditions observed in 15 evacuation drills in 10 nursery schools in the Czech Republic involving 970 children (3-7 years of age) and 87 staff members. Based on the analysis of video recordings, over 1800 data points describing pre-movement times, the interpretation of warning signals, the reactions and activities of staff members and children, levels of physical assistance provided to the children, and exiting strategies were gathered, interpreted, and compared to key literature findings. Our observations showed that pre-movement times measured during the drills ranged from 3 to 59 s, depending on experimental conditions, and physical help was provided to 25% of the participating children. The pre-movement behaviour of the participants was strongly influenced by the instructions provided to children as well as the daily routines, rules, and educational practices employed in the nursery schools. In addition, the principles of the affiliation model and role-rule model were identified as applicable to preschool children. To enable engineering applications (e.g., in evacuation modeling studies), findings are presented together with a set of nine behavioural statements regarding the pre-movement behaviour of preschool children.
Physics and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the research on the pre - movement behaviour of kindergarten children during fire evacuation. Specifically, through 15 evacuation drills, the author collected data from 970 children aged 3 - 7 and 87 staff in 10 kindergartens in the Czech Republic, aiming to explore the following issues: 1. **Pre - movement time**: What is the time interval from receiving the alarm signal to the first child leaving the classroom? What factors influence these times? 2. **Understanding and response to warning signals**: How do children understand and respond to the evacuation alarm? What is the impact of different types of alarm signals on their responses? 3. **Staff's behavior and activities**: What actions did the staff take during the pre - movement phase? Is the guidance and support they provided effective? 4. **Physical assistance needs**: How many children need physical help to complete the evacuation? What factors are related to this need? 5. **Exit strategy**: Which exit do children choose for evacuation? Who decides these choices? ### Main findings - **Pre - movement time range**: The pre - movement time measured in the study varies between 3 and 59 seconds, depending on the experimental conditions. - **Physical assistance needs**: Approximately 25% of the participating children need physical help. - **Factors influencing pre - movement behavior**: - The content of the instructions provided to children. - Daily routines, rules, and educational practices in kindergartens. - The preparedness and response methods of the staff. ### Importance of the study This study provides a new data set on the pre - movement behavior of young children during fire evacuation, which helps to improve existing evacuation models and provides a basis for designing safer evacuation plans. In addition, the research results can also be used to evaluate the evacuation capabilities of children of different ages and develop corresponding emergency plans. ### Behavioral statements For the convenience of engineering applications (e.g., evacuation modeling research), the study also proposes a set of nine behavioral statements regarding the pre - movement behavior of young children. These statements can help understand, quantify, and directly incorporate the pre - movement behavior of young children into life - safety analysis. ### Conclusion This study emphasizes the particularity of young children in fire evacuation and provides valuable data for fire protection engineers to better understand and simulate the behavioral characteristics of this group.