Daniel Bennett,Wojciech J. Jankowski,Gaurav Chaudhary,Efthimios Kaxiras,Robert-Jan Slager
Abstract:Recently, topologically nontrivial polarization textures have been predicted and observed in nanoscale systems. While these polarization textures are interesting and promising in terms of applications, their topology in general is yet to be fully understood. For example, the relation between topological polarization structures and band topology has not been explored, and polar domain structures are typically considered in topologically trivial systems. In particular, the local polarization in a crystal supercell is not well-defined, and typically calculated using approximations which do not satisfy gauge invariance. Furthermore, local polarization in supercells is typically approximated using calculations involving smaller unit cells, meaning the connection to the electronic structure of the supercell is lost. In this work, we propose a definition of local polarization which is gauge invariant and can be calculated directly from a supercell without approximations. We show using first-principles calculations for commensurate bilayer hexagonal boron nitride that our expressions for local polarization give the correct result at the unit cell level, which is a first approximation to the local polarization in a moiré superlattice. We also illustrate using an effective model that the local polarization can be directly calculated in real space. Finally, we discuss the relation between polarization and band topology, for which it is essential to have a correct definition of polarization textures.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects:
1. **Ambiguity in the Definition of Local Polarization**: In the crystal super - cell, the definition of local polarization is still unclear. Approximate methods are usually used for calculation, and these methods do not satisfy gauge invariance. For example, local polarization is usually approximated by calculating a smaller primitive cell, which leads to the loss of the connection with the super - cell electronic structure. The paper proposes a gauge - invariant definition of local polarization, which can be directly calculated from the super - cell without approximation.
2. **The Relationship between Polarization Texture and Band Topology**: The relationship between the topological properties of polarization texture and band topology has not been fully understood. Currently, polarization texture is usually considered in topologically trivial systems, and the relationship between polarization structure and band topology has not been explored. The paper discusses the importance of this relationship and emphasizes the necessity of correctly defining polarization texture.
3. **Physical Consequences of Polarization Texture**: The physical consequences of topologically non - trivial polarization texture are still unclear. Although recent studies have shown that ferroelectric switching can change the Chern number of topologically non - trivial systems, this is mainly the result of uniform polarization. Topologically non - trivial polarization texture may bring unique phenomena and requires further study. In addition, finding these physical consequences may also provide new methods for experimentally and indirectly detecting polarization topology.
### Specific Problems
1. **Origin of Polarization Texture**:
- Polarization can have non - trivial winding in real space, which depends on both the geometry of the system and the basic crystal symmetry of the material. For example, in the perovskite superlattice, the electrostatic boundary conditions at the interface make the uniform polarization in the ferroelectric layer energetically unfavorable, thus promoting the formation of multi - domain structures. However, this does not guarantee non - trivial topology; the 180° striped - domain structure is superior to single - domain polarization but is topologically trivial.
- By analyzing the space group, the paper shows that different mirror planes are broken by different local stackings, causing the polarization to point outward at the domain center and inward along the domain wall, forming a network composed of merons and anti - merons.
2. **The Relationship between Polarization and Band Topology**:
- Local polarization is usually defined in real space, while band topology is described in momentum space. Therefore, the relationship between the topological properties of polarization texture and band topology is unclear. Modern polarization theory has been extended to Chern insulators, but the similarities and interactions between polarization and band topology are still unclear.
- Recent studies have shown that polarization can affect the topological properties of the system. For example, in the layered MnBi₂Te₄, reversing the polarization through van der Waals slip can change the Chern number, thereby changing the quantum anomalous Hall conductivity. Therefore, a better understanding of the role of polarization in system properties is required.
3. **Physical Consequences**:
- The physical consequences of topologically non - trivial polarization texture are still unclear. Although ferroelectric switching can change the Chern number of topologically non - trivial systems, this is mainly the result of uniform polarization. Topologically non - trivial polarization texture may bring unique phenomena, such as new phase transitions or quantum effects.
- Finding these physical consequences not only helps to understand the properties of polarization texture but also can provide new methods for experimentally and indirectly detecting polarization topology, which currently requires very precise microscopic measurement techniques.
### Methods and Results
The paper proposes several methods for estimating local polarization and defines local polarization based on Born effective charge or Wannier center. These definitions are gauge - invariant and can be directly calculated in real space. The specific steps are as follows:
1. **Configuration Space Mapping**: By mapping local distortions to the configuration space, local polarization can be efficiently estimated. However, this method depends on the assumption that the distortion changes slowly in real space and is not applicable to rapidly changing properties (such as Peierls distortion, defects, dislocations, etc.).
2. **Real - Space Calculation**: The paper proposes a method for directly calculating local polarization in real space by calculating the Born effective charge in the super - cell. This method is not only gauge - invariant but also can retain the connection with the super - cell electronic structure.
3. **Effective Model Verification**: Through 1D (Aubry - André model) and 2D (Bistritzer - MacDonald model) effective models, the paper verifies the effectiveness of the proposed local polarization definition in real space.
In summary, this paper aims to solve the ambiguity in the definition of local polarization, explore the relationship between polarization texture and band topology, and study the physical consequences of topologically non - trivial polarization texture. By proposing gauge - invariant local polarization...