More than technical support: the professional contexts of physics instructional labs

LM Dana,Benjamin Pollard,Sara Mueller

2023-05-02

Abstract:Most, if not all, physics undergraduate degree programs include instructional lab experiences. Physics lab instructors, both faculty and staff, are instrumental to student learning in instructional physics labs. However, the faculty-staff dichotomy belies the complex, varied, and multifaceted landscape of positions that lab instructors hold in the fabrics of physics departments. Here we present the results of a mixed methods study of the people who teach instructional labs and their professional contexts. Recruiting physics lab instructors across the US, we collected 84 survey responses and conducted 12 in-depth interviews about their job characteristics, professional identities, resources, and experiences. Our investigation reveals that lab instructors vary in terms of their official titles, job descriptions, formal duties, personal agency, and access to resources. We also identified common themes around the value of instructional labs, mismatched job descriptions, and a broad set of necessary skills and expertise. Our results suggest that instructors often occupy overlapping roles that fall in between more canonical jobs in physics departments. By understanding the professional contexts of physics lab instructors, the rest of the physics community can better promote and engage with their critical work, improving laboratory learning both for students and for the lab instructors who teach and support them.

Physics Education

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are related to the professional backgrounds, role perceptions, resource acquisition, and laboratory value perception of teaching and support staff in physical experiment teaching laboratories. Specifically, the paper aims to:

1. **Understand the basic situation of personnel engaged in physical experiment teaching support and teaching**: including their job titles, experience, and social identities.
2. **Describe their views on their own roles**: especially regarding their responsibilities and autonomy.
3. **Explore their value perception of experimental teaching**: including their views in the local environment and those of the broader physics community on experimental teaching.

In addition, in order to provide necessary background information for the above - mentioned research questions, the paper also explores:

1. **The equipment and human resources available to these personnel**.
2. **Differences in resource availability under different institutional backgrounds**.

By answering these questions, researchers hope to promote, recognize, and support the personnel working in physical experiment teaching laboratories. Understanding their professional backgrounds is important for any experimental course reform, regardless of its specific teaching methods or learning objectives. This will not only help record research data but also be expected to be used to guide and improve the teaching reform of future physical experiment courses.