Chaos Near to the Critical Point: Butterfly Effect and Pole-Skipping

B. Amrahi,M. Asadi,F. Taghinavaz
2023-07-08
Abstract:We study the butterfly effect and pole-skipping phenomenon for the 1RCBH model which enjoys a critical point in its phase diagram. Using the holographic idea, we compute the butterfly velocity and interestingly find that this velocity can probe the critical behavior of this model. We calculate the dynamical exponent of this quantity near the critical point and find a perfect agreement with the value of the other quantity's dynamical exponent near this critical point. We also find that at chaos point, the phenomenon of pole-skipping appears which is a sign of a multivalued retarded correlation function. We briefly address the butterfly velocity and pole-skipping for the AdS-RN black hole solution which on its boundary a strongly coupled charged field theory lives. For both of these models, we find $v_B^2\geq c_s^2$ at each point of parameter space where $c_s$ is the speed of sound wave propagation.
High Energy Physics - Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects: 1. **Research on the Butterfly Effect**: The paper explores chaotic behavior by studying the butterfly effect in the 1RCBH model. Specifically, the author calculates the butterfly velocity ($v_B$) and finds that this velocity can detect the critical behavior of the model. They also calculate the dynamic exponent near the critical point and compare it with the dynamic exponents of other quantities in the literature, finding that they are completely consistent. In addition, the author also observes the pole - skipping phenomenon at the chaotic point, which is a sign of the multi - valued degenerate Green's function. 2. **Research on the Pole - Skipping Phenomenon**: The paper further explores the pole - skipping phenomenon in the 1RCBH model and the AdS - RN black hole solution. The author analyzes in detail the linearized equations of these models at the chaotic point and finds that the pole - skipping phenomenon is widespread in these models. In particular, at the chaotic point, the $v - v$ component of the Einstein equation becomes trivial, resulting in the appearance of additional normal modes, thus leading to the pole - skipping phenomenon. ### Main Research Contents - **Butterfly Effect**: - **Background Introduction**: The paper first introduces the background of the 1RCBH model, which is an analytic top - down string theory construction derived from the 5 - dimensional maximally symmetric gauge supergravity theory, and is dual to the 4 - dimensional strongly - coupled $N = 4$ SYM theory at a finite chemical potential through the global SU(4) symmetry of the U(1) subgroup. - **Shock Wave Geometry**: By constructing the shock wave geometry, the author calculates the butterfly velocity $v_B$ and finds that its behavior near the critical point is closely related to the critical behavior of the system. - **Calculation of Butterfly Velocity**: The author uses the holographic method to calculate the butterfly velocity $v_B$ in the 1RCBH model and obtains its explicit expression. The results show that the butterfly velocity $v_B$ can be used to detect the critical point of the system. - **Pole - Skipping Phenomenon**: - **Characteristics of the Chaotic Point**: At the chaotic point, the $v - v$ component of the Einstein equation becomes trivial, resulting in the appearance of additional normal modes, thus leading to the pole - skipping phenomenon. - **Analysis of Linearized Equations**: The author analyzes in detail the linearized equations of the 1RCBH model and the AdS - RN black hole solution at the chaotic point and finds that these equations exhibit multi - valuedness at the chaotic point, further confirming the existence of the pole - skipping phenomenon. ### Conclusion By studying the butterfly effect and the pole - skipping phenomenon in the 1RCBH model, the paper reveals the effectiveness of these phenomena in detecting the critical behavior of the system. In particular, the butterfly velocity $v_B$ is proven to be a very useful diagnostic tool for determining the location of the critical point of the system. In addition, the discovery of the pole - skipping phenomenon further deepens the understanding of chaotic behavior in strongly - coupled quantum field theories.