Threat Perception Modulation by Capturing Emotion, Motor and Empathetic System Responses: A Systematic Review

Elizabeth M. Jacobs,Fani Deligianni.,Frank Pollick

2023-04-29

Abstract:The fight or flight phenomena is of evolutionary origin and responsible for the type of defensive behaviours enacted, when in the face of threat. This review attempts to draw the link between fear and aggression as behavioural motivations for fight or flight defensive behaviours. Hence, this review intends to examine whether fight or flight behavioural responses are the result of fear and aggression. Furthermore, this review investigates whether human biological motion captures the affective states associated with the fight or flight phenomenon. This review also aims to investigate how threat informed emotion and motor systems have the potential to result in empathetic appraisal modulation. This is of interest to this systematic review, as empathetic modulation is crucial to prosocial drive, which has the potential to increase the inclination of alleviating the perceived threat of another. Hence, this review investigates the role of affective computing in capturing the potential outcome of empathy from threat perception. To gain a comprehensive understanding of the affective states and biological motion evoked from threat scenarios, affective computing methods used to capture these behavioural responses are discussed. A systematic review using Google Scholar and Web of Science was conducted as of 2023, and findings were supplemented by bibliographies of key articles. A total of 22 studies were analysed from initial web searches to explore the topics of empathy, threat perception, fight or flight, fear, aggression, and human motion. Relationships between affective states (fear, aggression) and corresponding motor defensive behaviours (fight or flight) were examined within threat scenarios, and whether existing affective computing methods are succinct in capturing these responses, identifying the varying consensus in the literature, challenges, and limitations of existing research.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore how threat perception regulates human behavior by capturing emotional, kinesthetic, and empathic system responses, particularly in the relationship between fear and aggressive behavior as well as the fight-or-flight response. The core objective of the paper is to understand how states of fear and aggression affect defensive behaviors of fight or flight, and to investigate whether human biological motion can accurately reflect these emotional states. Moreover, the study also focuses on how threat information facilitates empathic responses in observers, and how such regulation of empathic assessment affects prosocial behavior.

Specifically, the paper attempts to answer the following questions:
1. Are fear and aggression interrelated when facing threats, and do fight-or-flight behaviors arise from this?
2. Can biological human motion represent and capture measurable emotional states within the fight-or-flight phenomenon?
3. Which factors of threat perception modulate empathic responses, and how are these measured by emotional computation?
4. How does empathic assessment lead to prosocial behavior, and has this been measured by emotional computation?

To achieve these goals, the paper adopted a systematic review approach, conducting literature searches through Google Scholar and Web of Science databases, analyzing relevant studies up to the beginning of 2023. Ultimately, 22 studies were analyzed from the initial web search, discussing themes such as empathy, threat perception, fight or flight, fear, aggression, and human motion. The research also examined the relationship between emotional states (such as fear and aggression) and corresponding motor defensive behaviors (fight or flight) in threat scenarios, as well as whether existing emotional computation methods can accurately capture these responses. The paper also highlighted the importance of empathic assessment for prosocial drives, which has the potential to positively impact the mitigation of perceived threats to others. In summary, the paper seeks to comprehensively understand how emotional states and biological motion are elicited in threat scenarios, and the efficacy of emotional computation methods in capturing these states.