Abstract:In an extended Kyle's model, the interactions between a large informed trader and a high-frequency trader (HFT) who can anticipate the former's incoming order are studied. We find that, in equilibrium, HFT may play the role of Small-IT or Round-Tripper: both of them trade in the same direction as IT in advance, but when IT's order arrives, Small-IT continues to take liquidity away, while Round-Tripper supplies liquidity back. So Small-IT always harms IT, while Round-Tripper may benefit her. What's more, with an anticipatory HFT, normal-speed small uninformed traders suffer less and price discovery is accelerated.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the impact of High - Frequency Anticipatory Trading (HFAT) in the financial market. Specifically, the author studies the interaction between large Informed Traders (IT) and High - Frequency Traders (HFT) who can predict the former's future orders through an extended Kyle model. The core of the paper lies in exploring the impact of different roles of HFT - Small - Informed Trader (Small - IT) and Round - Tripper - on IT and market quality.
### Main Problems of the Paper
1. **Roles of HFT and Their Impact**:
- **Small - IT**: Before IT places an order, HFT establishes a position in the same direction as IT and continues to trade in the same direction after IT places an order. This strategy usually has a negative impact on IT.
- **Round - Tripper**: Before IT places an order, HFT establishes a position in the same direction as IT, but trades in the opposite direction after IT places an order, providing liquidity. This strategy may be beneficial to IT.
2. **Impact on Market Quality**:
- The study finds that the existence of predictive HFT can accelerate the price discovery process and reduce the losses of small uninformed traders at normal speed.
3. **Impact of Signal Accuracy and Inventory Aversion**:
- The signal accuracy and inventory aversion degree of HFT determine which strategy it adopts. When the inventory aversion degree of HFT is high, it is more inclined to play the role of Round - Tripper; otherwise, it is more inclined to play the role of Small - IT.
4. **Practical Application and Regulatory Suggestions**:
- The paper also discusses the impact of these theoretical results on the actual market, especially the implications for regulatory policies. For example, limiting the daily position of HFT may lead them to play the role of Round - Tripper more often, thus providing more liquidity and potentially benefiting other investors.
### Main Conclusions
- **Roles of HFT**: Under different conditions, HFT can play the role of Small - IT or Round - Tripper, and these two roles have completely different impacts on IT and market quality.
- **Market Quality**: The existence of HFT accelerates the price discovery process and reduces the losses of noise traders at normal speed.
- **Signal Accuracy and Inventory Aversion**: The signal accuracy and inventory aversion degree of HFT have an important impact on its strategy selection, which in turn affects the overall performance of the market.
### Model and Equilibrium
The paper constructs a two - stage dynamic market model, which extends the classic Kyle model. The model includes four types of participants: market makers, large Informed Traders (IT), High - Frequency Traders (HFT), and noise traders. By analyzing the strategies and profits of these participants, the paper obtains the optimal strategy of HFT under different conditions and its impact on the market.
### Numerical Analysis
The paper explores how the inventory aversion degree (Γ) and signal accuracy (θε) of HFT affect market equilibrium through a large number of numerical experiments. The results show that under different market noise levels (θ1), there are significant differences in the strategy selection of HFT and its impact on IT and market quality.
### Summary
This paper reveals the impact of HFT's predictive trading strategies on market quality and informed traders through in - depth analysis of the role of high - frequency traders in the financial market. The research results not only enrich the theoretical literature, but also provide valuable references for actual market operations and regulation.