Fifteen years of millimeter accuracy lunar laser ranging with APOLLO: data reduction and calibration

Nicholas R. Colmenares,James B. R. Battat,Daniel P. Gonzales,Thomas W. Murphy Jr.,Sanchit Sabhlok
2023-04-22
Abstract:The Apache Point Lunar Laser-ranging Operation (APOLLO) has been collecting lunar range measurements for 15 years at millimeter accuracy. The median nightly range uncertainty since 2006 is 1.7 mm. A recently added Absolute Calibration System (ACS), providing an independent assessment of APOLLO system accuracy and the capability to correct lunar range data, revealed a 0.4% systematic error in the calibration of one piece of hardware that has been present for the entire history of APOLLO. Application of ACS-based timing corrections suggests systematic errors are reduced to < 1 mm, such that overall data accuracy and precision are both 1 mm. This paper describes the processing of APOLLO/ACS data that converts photon-by-photon range measurements into the aggregated normal points that are used for physics analyses. Additionally we present methodologies to estimate timing corrections for range data lacking contemporaneous ACS photons, including range data collected prior to installation of the ACS. We also provide access to the full 15-year archive of APOLLO normal points (2006-04-06 to 2020-12-27).
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics,Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily addresses the issues of data processing and calibration for lunar laser ranging (LLR) with millimeter-level precision. Specifically, the Apache Point Lunar Laser-ranging Operation (APOLLO) system has collected high-precision lunar distance measurement data over the past 15 years. The paper describes how to convert single-photon level distance measurements into aggregated normal point data for physical analysis. The main contributions of the paper include: 1. **Data Correction and Accuracy Improvement**: The paper reveals a source of systematic error—approximately 0.4% bias in the calibration of the absolute time-to-digital converter (TDC), which has led to millimeter-level errors in measurements throughout the history of APOLLO. By applying corrections provided by the Absolute Calibration System (ACS), this systematic error can be reduced to less than 1 millimeter, thereby improving the overall accuracy and precision of the data to about 1 millimeter. 2. **Data Processing Workflow**: The paper details the workflow from raw data to final normal points, including how to use FID (local corner reflector return signals) and LUN (lunar return signals) to determine the round-trip time of the laser, and how to apply signals from the Absolute Calibration System for further correction. 3. **Role of the Absolute Calibration System**: The paper explains how the inclusion of the Absolute Calibration System (ACS) independently assesses the accuracy of the APOLLO system and checks for systematic errors. The ACS provides an independent time reference to correct systematic errors in lunar distance data. 4. **Long-term Data Analysis**: The paper also explores time differences between different channels over long periods and proposes a method to evaluate and correct these differences, further enhancing data quality. In summary, the focus of this paper is on improving the precision and accuracy of lunar laser ranging experiments, with detailed discussions on data processing and calibration.