Avoiding methane emission rate underestimates when using the divergence method

Clayton Roberts,Rutger IJzermans,David Randell,Matthew Jones,Philip Jonathan,Kaisey Mandel,Bill Hirst,Oliver Shorttle
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ad0252
2023-10-13
Abstract:Methane is a powerful greenhouse gas, and a primary target for mitigating climate change in the short-term future due to its relatively short atmospheric lifetime and greater ability to trap heat in Earth's atmosphere compared to carbon dioxide. Top-down observations of atmospheric methane are possible via drone and aircraft surveys as well as satellites such as the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument (TROPOMI). Recent work has begun to apply the divergence method to produce regional methane emission rate estimates. Here we show that when the divergence method is applied to spatially incomplete observations of methane, it can result in negatively biased time-averaged regional emission rates. We show that this effect can be counteracted by adopting a procedure in which daily advective fluxes of methane are time-averaged before the divergence method is applied. Using such a procedure with TROPOMI methane observations, we calculate yearly Permian emission rates of 3.1, 2.4 and 2.7 million tonnes per year for the years 2019 through 2021. We also show that highly-resolved plumes of methane can have negatively biased estimated emission rates by the divergence method due to the presence of turbulent diffusion in the plume, but this is unlikely to affect regional methane emission budgets constructed from TROPOMI observations of methane. The results from this work are expected to provide useful guidance for future implementations of the divergence method for emission rate estimation from satellite data -- be it for methane or other gaseous species in the atmosphere.
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics,Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,Geophysics,Applications
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to address the underestimation issue when using the divergence method to estimate methane emission rates, especially in cases of spatially incomplete observations. Specifically: 1. **Research Background**: Methane, as a potent greenhouse gas, has a relatively short atmospheric lifetime and strong heat absorption capacity, making it one of the primary targets for short-term climate mitigation. Drones, aircraft, and satellites (such as the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument, TROPOMI) can perform top-down observations of atmospheric methane. In recent years, the divergence method has been used to estimate regional methane emission rates from these observational data. 2. **Research Problem**: When the divergence method is applied to spatially incomplete methane observation data, it leads to an underestimation of the time-averaged regional emission rates. Additionally, when methane plumes exhibit turbulent diffusion, the divergence method may also underestimate the emission rates of the plumes. 3. **Solution**: The paper proposes an improved method, which involves first time-averaging the daily transport fluxes and then applying the divergence method. Using this approach, the authors calculated the methane emission rates in the Permian Basin from 2019 to 2021 using TROPOMI observation data and found that this method could estimate the emission rates more accurately. 4. **Case Analysis**: Taking the Permian Basin as an example, the study compared two different time-averaging methods (E1 and E2) and found that the E2 method performed better in handling spatially incomplete observation data, avoiding significant underestimation of the total emission rates. Additionally, the authors discussed the impact of turbulent diffusion on the accuracy of the divergence method and pointed out that in actual observation systems, the impact of turbulent diffusion on the results is relatively small. In summary, the paper aims to provide an improved application scheme of the divergence method to enhance the accuracy of methane emission rate estimation based on satellite data.