Abstract:The hydrogen Balmer decrement (e.g., $\rm H\alpha/H\beta$) is widely adopted as an indicator of the internal reddening of active galactic nuclei (AGNs). This is challenged by some low-luminosity AGNs (LLAGNs) and changing-look AGNs (CLAGNs), which have steep Balmer decrement but without strong evidence for absorption. We compile a sample of normal AGNs and CLAGNs with a wider distribution of bolometric Eddington ratio ($\lambda_{\rm Edd}=L_{\rm bol}/L_{\rm Edd}$) and find a strong negative correlation between $\rm H\alpha/H\beta$ and $\lambda_{\rm Edd}$, which suggests that the Balmer decrement is also accretion-rate dependent. We further explore the Balmer decrement based on the photoionization model using the Cloudy code by considering spectral energy distribution (SED) from the accretion disk with different accretion rates (e.g., disk/corona and truncated disk at high and low Eddington ratios, respectively). Both the standard disk and truncated disk predict a negative correlation of $\rm H\alpha/H\beta-\lambda_{\rm Edd}$, where the relation is steeper in the case of the truncated disk. The negative correlations are also explored in two single CLAGNs. The measured negative correlation of $\rm H\alpha/H\beta$ -- $\lambda_{\rm Edd}$ is mainly caused by the lower responsivity $({\rm dlog}L_{\rm line}/{\rm dlog}L_{\rm cont})$ in $\rm H\alpha$ relative to that in $\rm H\beta$, due to the larger optical depth in the former. We propose that the steep Balmer decrements in low-Eddington-ratio AGNs (e.g., some Seyferts 1.5-1.9 and CLAGNs) are not simply caused by absorption but mainly caused by the relatively low flux of ionizing photons.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper attempts to solve the problem of whether the abnormally steep hydrogen Balmer line ratios (e.g., Hα/Hβ) in Low-Luminosity AGNs (LLAGNs) and Changing-Look AGNs (CLAGNs) are solely caused by dust extinction. ### Background and Motivation 1. **Traditional Understanding of Balmer Line Ratios**: - Hydrogen Balmer line ratios (e.g., Hα/Hβ) are typically used as indicators of internal reddening in Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs). - The traditional view is that if the Hα/Hβ ratio is abnormally high, it may be due to dust extinction. 2. **Challenges and Questions**: - Some LLAGNs and CLAGNs exhibit abnormally steep Balmer line ratios without clear evidence of absorption. - These phenomena challenge the traditional dust extinction explanation, suggesting that other mechanisms might be at play. ### Research Objectives - **Explore the Relationship Between Balmer Line Ratios and Accretion Rates**: - By analyzing Balmer line ratios at different accretion rates, study their relationship with the Eddington ratio (λEdd). - Explore whether these relationships can be explained by photoionization models. - **Propose New Explanatory Mechanisms**: - Using photoionization models (with the Cloudy code) to simulate spectral energy distributions (SEDs) at different accretion rates, investigate how changes in SEDs at low accretion rates affect Balmer line ratios. - Propose that the steep Balmer line ratios in low Eddington ratio AGNs may be due to relatively low ionizing photon flux rather than simple dust extinction. ### Main Findings - **Negative Correlation Between Hα/Hβ and λEdd**: - A significant negative correlation between the Hα/Hβ ratio and the Eddington ratio was found in the sample. - AGNs with low Eddington ratios exhibit steeper Balmer line ratios, while those with high Eddington ratios show lower ratios. - **Support from Photoionization Models**: - Simulations of SEDs at different accretion rates using photoionization models show that both standard accretion disks and truncated accretion disks can predict the negative correlation between Hα/Hβ and λEdd. - Changes in SEDs at low accretion rates lead to higher Hα/Hβ ratios, consistent with observational results. ### Conclusions - **Impact of Low Accretion Rates**: - The steep Balmer line ratios in low Eddington ratio AGNs are likely due to relatively low ionizing photon flux rather than simple dust extinction. - This finding is significant for understanding the physical properties and evolution of AGNs. - **Directions for Further Research**: - Further observational data are needed to verify this conclusion, especially with a more extensive sample of black hole masses and Eddington ratios. - Explore other factors that might affect Balmer line ratios, such as collisional excitation. This paper provides a new explanatory mechanism through detailed analysis of LLAGNs and CLAGNs, offering a new perspective for understanding the physical properties of AGNs.

Steep Balmer decrement in weak AGNs may be not caused by dust extinction: clues from low-luminosity AGNs and changing-look AGNs

Reddening of the BLR and NLR in AGN From a Systematic Analysis of Balmer Decrement

Broad-line Balmer Decrements in Blue Active Galactic Nuclei

The variability of the broad-line Balmer decrement for quasars from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey reverberation mapping

Extremely Dense Gas around Little Red Dots and High-redshift AGNs: A Non-stellar Origin of the Balmer Break and Absorption Features

Steep Balmer Decrement in Quasars and Seyfert Ⅰ galaxies and Its Origin

The Steep Balmer Decrement of Quasars and Seyfert I Galaxies and its Origin

The relationship between X-ray and optical absorbers in active galactic nuclei

Attenuation from the optical to the extreme ultraviolet by dust associated with broad absorption line quasars: The driving force for outflows

Here There Be (Dusty) Monsters: High Redshift AGN are Dustier Than Their Hosts

AGN Reddening and Ultraviolet Extinction Curves from Hubble Space Telescope Spectra

Balmer Decrement Anomalies in Galaxies at z ~ 6 Found by JWST Observations: Density-Bounded Nebulae or Excited H I Clouds?

Coevolution of Broad Emission Lines and X-Ray Spectrum in Changing-look AGNs

Eddington ratio Distribution of X-ray selected broad-line AGNs at 1.0<z<2.2

Different dependence of narrow H$α$ line luminosity on optical continuum luminosity between starforming galaxies and Type-2 AGN: globally negative AGN feedback in local Type-2 AGN?

The case for cases B and C: intrinsic hydrogen line ratios of the broad-line region of active galactic nuclei, reddenings, and accretion disc sizes

Understanding the Broad-line Region of Active Galactic Nuclei with Photoionization. I. the Moderate-Accretion Regime

Reddening and the Shape of the Variable Component of the Continua of Active Galactic Nuclei From the Optical to the Far Ultraviolet. I

Balmer Decrement Anomalies in Galaxies at z ∼ 6 Found by JWST Observations: Density-bounded Nebulae or Excited H i Clouds?