The Primordial Black Holes that Disappeared: Connections to Dark Matter and MHz-GHz Gravitational Waves

Thomas C. Gehrman,Barmak Shams Es Haghi,Kuver Sinha,Tao Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1475-7516/2023/10/001
2023-10-13
Abstract:In the post-LIGO era, there has been a lot of focus on primordial black holes (PBHs) heavier than $\sim 10^{15}$g as potential dark matter (DM) candidates. We point out that the branch of the PBH family that disappeared - PBHs lighter than $\sim 10^9$g that ostensibly Hawking evaporated away in the early Universe - also constitute an interesting frontier for DM physics. Hawking evaporation itself serves as a portal through which such PBHs can illuminate new physics, for example by emitting dark sector particles. Taking a simple DM scalar singlet model as a template, we compute the abundance and mass of PBHs that could have provided, by Hawking evaporation, the correct DM relic density. We consider two classes of such PBHs: those originating from curvature perturbations generated by inflation, and those originating from false vacuum collapse during a first-order phase transition. For PBHs of both origins we compute the gravitational wave (GW) signals emanating from their formation stage: from second-order effects in the case of curvature perturbations, and from sound waves in the case of phase transitions. The GW signals have peak frequencies in the MHz-GHz range typical of such light PBHs. We compute the strength of such GWs compatible with the observed DM relic density, and find that the GW signal morphology can in principle allow one to distinguish between the two PBH formation histories.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore how light primordial black holes (Primordial Black Holes, PBHs) are related to dark matter (Dark Matter, DM) and gravitational waves (Gravitational Waves, GWs) in the megahertz - gigahertz frequency range after disappearing through Hawking radiation in the early universe. Specifically, the paper focuses on primordial black holes with a mass less than about \(10^9\) grams, which have completely evaporated through Hawking radiation before Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (Big Bang Nucleosynthesis, BBN). The main objectives of the paper are: 1. **Explore the possibility of light primordial black holes as dark matter candidates**: - Calculate the abundance and mass of dark matter particles produced by these light primordial black holes through Hawking radiation. - Consider two different primordial black hole formation mechanisms: primordial black holes generated by curvature perturbations during inflation and primordial black holes generated by first - order phase transitions (First - Order Phase Transition, FOPT). 2. **Study the high - frequency gravitational wave signals generated during the formation of primordial black holes**: - For primordial black holes generated by curvature perturbations, the gravitational wave signals mainly come from second - order effects. - For primordial black holes generated by first - order phase transitions, the gravitational wave signals mainly come from sound waves. 3. **Evaluate the intensity of these gravitational wave signals and explore their relationship with the dark matter abundance**: - Calculate the form of gravitational wave signals consistent with the observed dark matter relic density. - Explore whether the characteristics of gravitational wave signals can distinguish these two mechanisms under different primordial black hole formation mechanisms. ### Main content 1. **Introduction**: - Introduces the classification of primordial black holes, especially stable primordial black holes with a mass greater than \(10^{15}\) grams and evaporated primordial black holes with a mass less than \(10^9\) grams. - Emphasizes the importance of research on light primordial black holes after disappearing through Hawking radiation and their potential value in dark matter physics. 2. **Dark matter produced by Hawking radiation**: - Describes the basic principle of Hawking radiation and the mass evolution of primordial black holes during the radiation - dominated era. - Calculates the number and abundance of dark matter particles produced by Hawking radiation. 3. **Primordial black hole formation mechanisms and their related gravitational waves**: - **First - order phase transition**: Discusses the mechanism of primordial black hole formation during the first - order phase transition and the calculation of related gravitational wave signals. - **Curvature perturbation**: Describes the mechanism of primordial black hole formation by curvature perturbations during inflation and the calculation of related gravitational wave signals. 4. **Results: Dark matter and high - frequency gravitational waves**: - Gives the parameter relationships related to the dark matter abundance, such as the relationships between \(\Omega_\chi h^2\) and \(m_\chi\) with \(M_{\text{PBH}}\) and \(\beta_{\text{PBH}}\). - Calculates the high - frequency gravitational wave signals under different primordial black hole formation mechanisms and discusses the detection prospects of these signals. 5. **Conclusion**: - Summarizes the research results of dark matter and high - frequency gravitational waves produced by light primordial black holes through Hawking radiation. - Emphasizes the detection potential of future experiments for these signals, especially in the MHz - GHz frequency range. ### Mathematical formulas - **Hawking temperature**: \[ T_{\text{PBH}}(t)=\frac{M_{\text{Pl}}^2}{8\pi M_{\text{PBH}}(t)} \] - **Hawking radiation energy spectrum**: \[ \frac{d^2 u_\chi(E, t)}{dt dE}=\frac{g_\chi}{8\pi^2}\frac{E^3}{e^{E/T_{\text{PBH}}(t)}\pm1} \] (+ indicates fermion emission, - indicates boson emission) - **Evolution of primordial black hole mass with time**: \[ M_{\t