Outflows in the Gaseous Discs of Active Galaxies and their impact on Black Hole Scaling Relations

N. Menci,F. Fiore,F. Shankar,L. Zanisi,C. Feruglio
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202244574
2023-04-17
Abstract:To tackle the still unsolved and fundamental problem of the role of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) feedback in shaping galaxies, in this work we implement a new physical treatment of AGN-driven winds into our semi-analytic model of galaxy formation. To each galaxy in our model, we associate solutions for the outflow expansion and the mass outflow rates in different directions, depending on the AGN luminosity, on the circular velocity of the host halo, and on gas content of the considered galaxy. To each galaxy we also assign an effective radius derived from energy conservation during merger events, and a stellar velocity dispersion self-consistently computed via Jeans modelling. We derive all the main scaling relations between Black hole (BH) mass and total/bulge stellar mass, velocity dispersion, host halo dark matter mass, and star formation efficiency. We find that our improved AGN feedback mostly controls the dispersion around the relations but plays a subdominant role in shaping slopes and/or normalizations of the scaling relations. Including possible limited-resolution selection biases in the model provides better agreement with the available data. The model does not point to any more fundamental galactic property linked to BH mass, with velocity dispersion playing a similar role with respect to stellar mass, in tension with present data. In line with other independent studies carried out on comprehensive semi-analytic and hydrodynamic galaxy-BH evolution models, our current results signal either an inadequacy of present cosmological models of galaxy formation in fully reproducing the local scaling relations, in terms of both shape and residuals, and/or point to an incompleteness issue affecting the local sample of dynamically-measured BHs.
Astrophysics of Galaxies,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to explore the role of Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN) feedback in shaping galaxies, particularly how AGN-driven outflows affect the scaling relations between black hole mass and host galaxy properties. Specifically, the researchers simulate the impact of AGN-driven outflows on mass outflow rates and outflow expansion in different directions by introducing new physical treatment methods into semi-analytical galaxy formation models. These simulations consider factors such as AGN luminosity, the circular velocity of the host halo, and the gas content of the galaxies under consideration. ### Main Research Content 1. **Model Improvements**: - Introduced a new physical description method to simulate the expansion of AGN-driven outflows in a disk-like geometric structure. - The model is based on a 2D description, considering the expansion paths of outflows in different directions, particularly perpendicular to the disk plane and along the disk plane. - The model also calculates the changes in outflow velocity, mass outflow rate, and shockwave position over time. 2. **Parameter Selection**: - Used a grid of input parameter sets, including AGN luminosity, gas mass, and the circular velocity of the host galaxy. - For each parameter combination, the expansion, velocity, and mass outflow rate of outflows in different directions were calculated. 3. **Results Analysis**: - Investigated the main scaling relations between black hole mass and total stellar mass, stellar mass of the galactic bulge, stellar velocity dispersion, host halo dark matter mass, and star formation efficiency. - Found that the improved AGN feedback mainly controls the scatter in these relations but plays a secondary role in determining the slope and normalization. - Considered possible selection biases to better match existing data. 4. **Impact of Observational Biases**: - Explored observational biases that may affect local dynamical measurements of supermassive black hole samples, particularly selection effects related to angular resolution. - Analyzed how these biases impact the comparison between theoretical predictions and observed scaling relations. ### Conclusion This study reveals the impact of AGN-driven outflows on black hole-galaxy scaling relations through an improved AGN feedback model. Although the improved model has made progress in explaining certain observational data, there are still some shortcomings, such as the inability to fully reproduce the shape and residuals of local scaling relations. This suggests that current cosmological models may have deficiencies in fully reproducing local scaling relations in the galaxy formation process, or there may be issues with the completeness of dynamical measurements of black holes in local samples.