Assisting clinical practice with fuzzy probabilistic decision trees

Emma L. Ambags,Giulia Capitoli,Vincenzo L' Imperio,Michele Provenzano,Marco S. Nobile,Pietro Liò

2023-04-27

Abstract:The need for fully human-understandable models is increasingly being recognised as a central theme in AI research. The acceptance of AI models to assist in decision making in sensitive domains will grow when these models are interpretable, and this trend towards interpretable models will be amplified by upcoming regulations. One of the killer applications of interpretable AI is medical practice, which can benefit from accurate decision support methodologies that inherently generate trust. In this work, we propose FPT, (MedFP), a novel method that combines probabilistic trees and fuzzy logic to assist clinical practice. This approach is fully interpretable as it allows clinicians to generate, control and verify the entire diagnosis procedure; one of the methodology's strength is the capability to decrease the frequency of misdiagnoses by providing an estimate of uncertainties and counterfactuals. Our approach is applied as a proof-of-concept to two real medical scenarios: classifying malignant thyroid nodules and predicting the risk of progression in chronic kidney disease patients. Our results show that probabilistic fuzzy decision trees can provide interpretable support to clinicians, furthermore, introducing fuzzy variables into the probabilistic model brings significant nuances that are lost when using the crisp thresholds set by traditional probabilistic decision trees. We show that FPT and its predictions can assist clinical practice in an intuitive manner, with the use of a user-friendly interface specifically designed for this purpose. Moreover, we discuss the interpretability of the FPT model.

Machine Learning,Artificial Intelligence,Quantitative Methods

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to address the issue of interpretability of artificial intelligence (AI) models in clinical practice and proposes a new method—Fuzzy Probabilistic Decision Tree (FPT) to aid clinical decision-making. #### Research Background and Motivation In the medical field, AI systems are used to assist doctors in complex decision-making processes to improve the quality of patient care. However, due to issues of trust and transparency, the application of these systems remains limited. Traditional black-box models are unacceptable in the medical field because doctors need to be able to explain the logic behind their decisions. Therefore, researchers are increasingly focusing on the interpretability and transparency of AI models. #### Proposed Method The paper proposes a new method that combines probabilistic trees and fuzzy logic—**Fuzzy Probabilistic Decision Tree (FPT)**. This method allows doctors to generate, control, and verify the entire diagnostic process, thereby reducing the frequency of misdiagnosis and providing uncertainty estimates and counterfactual analysis. FPT is fully interpretable, allowing doctors to intuitively understand the working principles of the model. #### Application Cases The paper applies FPT to two real-world medical scenarios: 1. **Thyroid Nodule Classification**: Distinguishing between benign and malignant thyroid nodules. 2. **Chronic Kidney Disease Progression Prediction**: Predicting the risk of chronic kidney disease patients progressing to end-stage renal disease (ESRD) within the next 2 years. Through these two case studies, the paper demonstrates the application effectiveness of FPT in clinical practice and proves its generalizability across different disease types. Additionally, the paper designs a user-friendly interface tool that allows doctors to interact intuitively with the decision algorithm.

Assisting clinical practice with fuzzy probabilistic decision trees

A Decision Tree-Initialised Neuro-fuzzy Approach for Clinical Decision Support

POETREE: Interpretable Policy Learning with Adaptive Decision Trees

Uncertainty Quantification and Interpretability for Clinical Trial Approval Prediction

Personalized and Reliable Decision Sets: Enhancing Interpretability in Clinical Decision Support Systems

Fuzzy Inference System with Interpretable Fuzzy Rules: Advancing Explainable Artificial Intelligence for Disease Diagnosis—A Comprehensive Review

Integrating human expertise & automated methods for a dynamic and multi-parametric evaluation of large language models' feasibility in clinical decision-making

Group Probability-Weighted Tree Sums for Interpretable Modeling of Heterogeneous Data

Intelligent medical diagnosis and treatment for diabetes with deep convolutional fuzzy neural networks

Classification and Prediction Evaluation of a Fuzzy Rule-Based Model for Diabetes Diagnosis, Level of Care and Pima Indians Diabetes Datasets

The fuzzy medical group in the centre for computational intelligence

MS-CPFI: A model-agnostic Counterfactual Perturbation Feature Importance algorithm for interpreting black-box Multi-State models

Evaluating Explainable Machine Learning Models for Clinicians

A General Fuzzy Cerebellar Model Neural Network Multidimensional Classifier Using Intuitionistic Fuzzy Sets for Medical Identification

Standing on FURM ground -- A framework for evaluating Fair, Useful, and Reliable AI Models in healthcare systems

The Fundamental Nature of Interpretability in Diagnosing Diabetes Using Neuro-Fuzzy Classifier

A psychometric modeling approach to fuzzy rating data

Interpretable Machine Learning Classifiers for Brain Tumour Survival Prediction

An Interpretable Client Decision Tree Aggregation process for Federated Learning

Decision Tree Learning for Uncertain Clinical Measurements

Constrained neuro fuzzy inference methodology for explainable personalised modelling with applications on gene expression data