Nuclear recoil response of liquid xenon and its impact on solar 8B neutrino and dark matter searches

X. Xiang,R.J. Gaitskell,R. Liu,J. Bang,J. Xu,W.H. Lippincott,J. Aalbers,J.E.Y. Dobson,M. Szydagis,G.R.C. Rischbieter,N. Parveen,D.Q. Huang,I. Olcina,R.J. James,J.A. Nikoleyczik

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.108.022007

2023-04-13

Abstract:Knowledge of the ionization and scintillation responses of liquid xenon (LXe) to nuclear recoils is crucial for LXe-based dark matter experiments. Current calibrations carry large uncertainties in the low-energy region below $\sim3$ keV$_nr$ where signals from dark matter particles of $<$10 GeV/c$^2$ masses are expected. The coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering (CE$\nu$NS) by solar $^8$B neutrinos also results in a continuum of nuclear recoil events below 3.0 keV$_{nr}$ (99\% of events), which further complicates low-mass dark matter searches in LXe experiments. In this paper, we describe a method to quantify the uncertainties of low-energy LXe responses using published calibration data, followed by case studies to evaluate the impact of yield uncertainties on ${^8}$B searches and low-mass dark matter sensitivity in a typical ton-scale LXe experiment. We conclude that naively omitting yield uncertainties leads to overly optimistic limits by factor $\sim2$ for a 6 GeV/c$^2$ WIMP mass. Future nuclear recoil light yield calibrations could allow experiments to recover this sensitivity and also improve the accuracy of solar ${^8}$B flux measurements.

High Energy Physics - Experiment,Instrumentation and Detectors

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are the uncertainties of liquid xenon (LXe) in response to nuclear recoils in the low - energy region (below about 3 keV nr), and the impact of these uncertainties on the coherent elastic scattering of solar 8B neutrinos (CE νNS) and low - mass dark matter detection. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Uncertainties of low - energy nuclear recoil response**: Current calibration data have large uncertainties in the low - energy region, especially in the low - energy area where signals from dark matter particles with a mass of <10 GeV/c² are expected. These uncertainties will affect the sensitivity of experiments to low - mass dark matter particles.

2. **Impact of the solar 8B neutrino background**: Nuclear recoil events generated by the coherent elastic scattering of solar 8B neutrinos form a continuous background. Most of the energy of these events is below 3.0 keV nr (99% of the events), which further complicates the search for low - mass dark matter. These background events are difficult to distinguish from low - mass dark matter signals, thus posing a challenge to dark matter detection.

3. **Methods and evaluation**: The paper proposes a method to quantify the uncertainties of the low - energy LXe response and evaluates the impact of these uncertainties on the 8B neutrino search and low - mass dark matter sensitivity through case studies. Research shows that ignoring these uncertainties will lead to overly optimistic limits on the 6 GeV WIMP mass, which is approximately overestimated by a factor of 2.

4. **Future prospects**: Future nuclear recoil light - yield calibrations can restore these sensitivities and improve the accuracy of solar 8B flux measurements.

### Overview of the paper structure

- **Introduction**: Introduces the development of liquid xenon dark matter experiments, especially the current status of multi - ton LXe experiments such as LUX - ZEPLIN (LZ), XENON - nT and PandaX - 4T, and the importance of these experiments in detecting low - energy nuclear recoil signals.

- **Models and methods**:
- **Selecting published data**: Reviews the LXe nuclear recoil calibration data published in the past decade and describes the method used to quantify the uncertainties of low - energy yields.
- **Yield model based on NEST**: Proposes a simplified model to capture the uncertainties in the low - energy region, which is achieved by linearly parameterizing the NEST default yield curve.

- **Physical case studies**:
- **Detection efficiency**: Evaluates the detection efficiency of low - energy nuclear recoils and its uncertainties, especially under different S1 and S2 threshold settings.
- **Constraints on 8B flux**: Evaluates the ability of experiments to measure the 8B neutrino flux through Monte Carlo simulation data, considering the impact of yield uncertainties.
- **WIMP sensitivity**: Evaluates the sensitivity of experiments to WIMP in the presence of 8B neutrino background, especially the exclusion limits for low - mass WIMP.

- **Discussion and conclusion**: Discusses strategies for reducing yield uncertainties and summarizes the main results, emphasizing the importance of future improvements in calibration.

Through these studies, the paper aims to provide a more accurate low - energy nuclear recoil response model for liquid xenon dark matter experiments, thereby improving the experimental detection capabilities for low - mass dark matter and solar 8B neutrinos.