Characteristics of LIS Research Articles Affecting Their Citation Impact

Kalervo Jarvelin,Yu-Wei Chang,Pertti Vakkari

2023-04-11

Abstract:The paper analyses the citation impact of Library and Information Science, LIS for short, research articles published in 31 leading international LIS journals in 2015. The main research question is: to what degree do authors' disciplinary composition in association with other content characteristics of LIS articles affect their citation impact? The impact is analysed in terms of the number of citations received and their authority, using outlier normalization and subfield normalization. The article characteristics analysed using quantitative content analysis include topic, methodology, type of contribution, and the disciplinary composition of their author teams. The citations received by the articles are traced from 2015 to May 2021. Citing document authority is measured by the citations they had received up to May 2021. The overall finding was that authors' disciplinary composition is significantly associated with citation scores. The differences in citation scores between disciplinary compositions appeared typically within information retrieval and scientific communication. In both topics LIS and computer science jointly received significantly higher citation scores than many disciplines like LIS alone or humanities in information retrieval, or natural sciences, medicine, or social sciences alone in scientific communication. The paper is original in allowing joint analysis of content, authorship composition, and impact.

Digital Libraries,Social and Information Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How do the content characteristics of Library and Information Science (LIS) research articles affect their citation influence? Specifically, how do the disciplinary composition of the author team and other content characteristics (such as topic, methodology, type of contribution) jointly affect the citation influence of the article.

The paper explores the following aspects by analyzing the articles published in 31 major international LIS journals in 2015:

1. **Research questions**:
- What is the impact of the disciplinary composition of the author team on the citation influence of the article?
- What is the combined impact of the disciplinary composition and other content characteristics (such as research topic, research strategy, type of contribution) on the citation influence of the article?

2. **Research background**:
- Citation influence analysis plays an important role in research evaluation. Understanding which factors affect citation influence is crucial for the evaluation of scientific research.
- Previous studies have mostly focused on the normative citation reasons in bibliometrics, while this paper focuses on descriptive factors, such as the disciplinary composition of the author team, research topic, methodology, etc.

3. **Research methods**:
- Through quantitative content analysis of LIS articles published in 2015, information such as the topic, methodology, and type of contribution of the articles was collected.
- The citation situation of these articles from 2015 to May 2021 was analyzed, and the influence of the articles was measured by the number of citations and citation authority.
- Logarithmic smoothing and sub - field normalization methods were used to process citation data to reduce the impact of outliers and improve the comparability of results.

4. **Research findings**:
- The disciplinary composition of the author team significantly affects the citation influence of the article. For example, articles co - authored by LIS and computer science usually have higher citation influence.
- Different disciplinary combinations also perform differently on different research topics. For example, in the field of information retrieval, articles co - authored by LIS and computer science have higher citation influence than those written solely by LIS scholars.

In short, this paper aims to reveal how the content characteristics of LIS research articles affect their citation influence and provide suggestions on how to design research projects, plan doctoral programs, and plan the careers of individual scholars.