On the half-quantized Hall conductance of massive surface electrons in magnetic topological insulator films

Rui Chen,Shun-Qing Shen

2023-04-09

Abstract:In topological insulators, massive surface bands resulting from local symmetry breaking are believed to exhibit a half-quantized Hall conductance. However, such scenarios are obviously inconsistent with the Thouless-Kohmoto-Nightingale-Nijs theorem, which states that a single band in a lattice with a finite Brillouin zone can only have an integer-quantized Hall conductance. To explore this, we investigate the band structures of a lattice model describing the magnetic topological insulator film that supports the axion insulator, Chern insulator, and semi-magnetic topological insulator phases. We reveal that the gapped and gapless surface bands in the three phases are characterized by an integer-quantized Hall conductance and a half-quantized Hall conductance, respectively. This result is distinct from the previous consensus that the gapped surface band is responsible for the half-quantized Hall conductance and the gapless band should exhibit zero Hall response. We propose an effective model to describe the three phases and show that the low-energy dispersion of the surface bands inherits from the surface Dirac fermions. The gapped surface band manifests a nearly half-quantized Hall conductance at low energy near the center of Brillouin zone, but is compensated by another nearly half-quantized Hall conductance at high energy near the boundary of Brillouin zone because a single band can only have an integer-quantized Hall conductance. The gapless state hosts a zero Hall conductance at low energy but is compensated by another half-quantized Hall conductance at high energy, and thus the half-quantized Hall conductance can only originate from the gapless band. Moreover, we calculate the layer-resolved Hall conductance of the system. The conclusion suggests that the individual gapped surface band alone does not support the half-quantized surface Hall effect in a lattice model.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether massive surface electrons in magnetic topological insulator thin films can exhibit half - quantized Hall conductance. Specifically, this problem contradicts the Thouless - Kohmoto - Nightingale - Nijs (TKNN) theorem, which states that in a two - dimensional lattice model of a finite Brillouin zone, a single energy band can only have an integer - quantized Hall conductance (i.e., \( \sigma = n\frac{e^{2}}{h} \), where \( n \) is an integer).

However, the previous consensus was that massive surface Dirac fermions resulting from local symmetry breaking could produce half - quantized Hall conductance (i.e., \( \sigma=\frac{1}{2}\frac{e^{2}}{h} \)). This contradiction led the authors to deeply study the energy band structure in magnetic topological insulator thin films and explore how these energy bands can exhibit half - quantized Hall conductance in the lattice model.

To this end, the authors studied three different phases: the Aharonov - Bohm (Axion) insulator, the Chern insulator, and the half - magnetic topological insulator. Through numerical calculations and theoretical analysis, the authors revealed the following:

1. **Aharonov - Bohm (Axion) insulator and Chern insulator**:
- In the low - energy region (close to the center of the Brillouin zone), each band - gap surface state contributes approximately half - quantized Hall conductance.
- In the high - energy region (close to the Brillouin zone boundary), it must be compensated by another approximately half - quantized Hall conductance to ensure that the total conductance is integer - quantized.

2. **Half - magnetic topological insulator**:
- The low - energy region exhibits zero Hall conductance.
- The high - energy region contributes half - quantized Hall conductance, so the total Hall conductance is half - quantized.

3. **Layer - resolved Hall conductance**:
- The authors also calculated the layer - resolved Hall conductance, and the results showed that the half - quantized Hall effect is the result of the contribution of all occupied bands, rather than being determined solely by a single band - gap surface state.

4. **Effective model**:
- An effective four - band model was proposed to describe these three phases, confirming that the low - energy surface states are inherited from Dirac fermions and that there is a coupling effect between low - and high - energy states.

Through these studies, the authors resolved the contradiction between half - quantized Hall conductance and the TKNN theorem and revealed the specific manifestation mechanisms of Hall conductance in different phases.