Wiener-Hopf factorization approach to a bulk-boundary correspondence and stability conditions for topological zero-energy modes

Abhijeet Alase,Emilio Cobanera,Gerardo Ortiz,Lorenza Viola
2023-04-07
Abstract:Both the physics and applications of fermionic symmetry-protected topological phases rely heavily on a principle known as bulk-boundary correspondence, which predicts the emergence of protected boundary-localized energy excitations (boundary states) if the bulk is topologically non-trivial. Current theoretical approaches formulate a bulk-boundary correspondence as an equality between a bulk and a boundary topological invariant, where the latter is a property of boundary states. However, such an equality does not offer insight about the stability or the sensitivity of the boundary states to external perturbations. To solve this problem, we adopt a technique known as the Wiener-Hopf factorization of matrix functions. Using this technique, we first provide an elementary proof of the equality of the bulk and the boundary invariants for one-dimensional systems with arbitrary boundary conditions in all Altland-Zirnbauer symmetry classes. This equality also applies to quasi-one-dimensional systems (e.g., junctions) formed by bulks belonging to the same symmetry class. We then show that only topologically non-trivial Hamiltonians can host stable zero-energy edge modes, where stability refers to continuous deformation of zero-energy excitations with external perturbations that preserve the symmetries of the class. By leveraging the Wiener-Hopf factorization, we establish bounds on the sensitivity of such stable zero-energy modes to external perturbations. Our results show that the Wiener-Hopf factorization is a natural tool to investigate bulk-boundary correspondence in quasi-one-dimensional fermionic symmetry-protected topological phases. Our results on the stability and sensitivity of zero modes are especially valuable for applications, including Majorana-based topological quantum computing.
Statistical Mechanics,Mathematical Physics,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper is mainly devoted to solving problems related to the stability of topological zero - energy modes and their sensitivity to external perturbations. Specifically, by using the Wiener - Hopf factorization technique, the paper has solved the following key problems: 1. **Proof of bulk - boundary correspondence**: - The author provides an elementary proof method to prove that in all Altland - Zirnbauer symmetry classifications, the bulk - boundary invariants of one - dimensional systems are equal under arbitrary boundary conditions. - This equality also applies to quasi - one - dimensional systems (e.g., junctions) formed by the bulk of the same symmetry class. 2. **Stability of topologically non - trivial Hamiltonians**: - The author proves that only topologically non - trivial Hamiltonians can carry stable zero - energy edge modes, where stability refers to the continuous deformation of zero - energy excitations under external perturbations that preserve symmetry. - By using Wiener - Hopf factorization, the author establishes the bounds of the sensitivity of these stable zero - energy modes to external perturbations. 3. **Number and stability of zero - energy modes**: - The paper explores whether the number of zero - energy modes has topological significance and whether the invariance of these numbers can be predicted from the bulk properties of the system. - The author points out that the number of zero - energy modes determines the ground - state degeneracy of non - interacting many - body fermionic systems, and this degeneracy is used to store quantum information in topological quantum memories. 4. **Sensitivity of zero - energy modes to external perturbations**: - The author introduces a quantitative sensitivity measure and derives an upper bound, which only depends on the Bloch Hamiltonian. - The conclusion shows that the zero - energy modes of flat - band Hamiltonians are the least sensitive to external perturbations. ### Main contributions - **Spectral flattening to "dimer" Hamiltonians**: - A systematic method is proposed to connect any quasi - one - dimensional Hamiltonian to a canonical "dimerized" flat - band Bloch Hamiltonian through homotopy (i.e., adiabatic deformation) without leaving the appropriate symmetry class. - This method is applicable to periodic and semi - open boundary conditions. - **Bulk - boundary correspondence under open boundary conditions**: - A strict bulk - boundary correspondence is proved, which is applicable to clean quasi - one - dimensional systems and takes boundary disorder into account. - The results are extended to junctions, assuming that the bulk and tunnel Hamiltonians forming the junctions satisfy the same symmetry. - **Stability of the topological zero - energy mode manifold**: - A good quantization index for measuring the stability of the zero - energy mode manifold is identified, and it is proved that only topologically non - trivial Hamiltonians can carry certain stable zero - energy modes. - Examples are provided to illustrate that not all topological zero - energy modes are stable. - **Sensitivity of the zero - energy mode manifold to external perturbations**: - A quantitative sensitivity measure is introduced and an upper bound is derived, which only depends on the Bloch Hamiltonian. - The conclusion shows that the zero - energy modes of flat - band Hamiltonians are the least sensitive to external perturbations. ### Central mathematical tools - **Wiener - Hopf factorization**: - The main mathematical tool in this paper is the Wiener - Hopf factorization of single - variable matrix functions. - The author proves that there are a series of variants of the standard Wiener - Hopf factorization, called symmetric Wiener - Hopf (SWH) factorizations, which are consistent in certain symmetry classes. - These factorizations are systematically calculated by an iterative algorithm and form the basis of all the results in the paper. ### Summary Through the Wiener - Hopf factorization technique, this paper conducts an in - depth study of the bulk - boundary correspondence in quasi - one - dimensional topological phases, the stability of zero - energy modes and their sensitivity to external perturbations. These results not only provide new theoretical insights but also have important value in applications, especially in topological quantum computing.