Abstract:Despite the increasing number of three-dimensional (3D) model portals and online repositories catering for digital heritage scholars, students and interested members of the general public, there are very few recent academic publications that offer a critical analysis when reviewing the relative potential of these portals and online repositories. Solid reviews of the features and functions they offer are insufficient; there is also a lack of explanations as to how these assets and their related functionality can further the digital heritage (and virtual heritage) field, and help in the preservation, maintenance, and promotion of real-world 3D heritage sites and assets. What features do they offer? How could their feature list better cater for the needs of the GLAM (galleries, libraries, archives and museums) sector? This article’s priority is to examine the useful features of 8 institutional and 11 commercial repositories designed specifically to host 3D digital models. The available features of their associated 3D viewers, where applicable, are also analysed, connecting recommendations for future-proofing with the need to address current gaps and weaknesses in the scholarly field of 3D digital heritage. Many projects do not address the requirements stipulated by charters, such as access, reusability, and preservation. The lack of preservation strategies and examples highlights the oxymoronic nature of virtual heritage (oxymoronic in the sense that the virtual heritage projects themselves are seldom preserved). To study these concerns, six criteria for gauging the usefulness of the 3D repositories to host 3D digital models and related digital assets are suggested. The authors also provide 13 features that would be useful additions for their 3D viewers. Highlights: A survey of relevant features from eight institutional and eleven commercial online 3D repositories in the scholarly fieldof 3D digital heritage. Presents a critical review of their hosting services and 3D model viewer features. Proposes six features to enhance services of 3D repositories to support the GLAM sector, heritage scholars andheritage communities.

A Checklist to Publish Collections as Data in GLAM Institutions

The "Collections as ML Data" Checklist for Machine Learning & Cultural Heritage

Digitization of GLAM Collections and Copyright: Policy Paper

Microsoft Cloud-based Digitization Workflow with Rich Metadata Acquisition for Cultural Heritage Objects

Community-developed checklists for publishing images and image analysis

Survey of 3D digital heritage repositories and platforms

Envisaging a global infrastructure to exploit the potential of digitised collections

Visualization of Cultural Heritage Collection Data: State of the Art and Future Challenges

Open data and digital morphology

Digital Collections as Data: A New Direction for Libraries

EUFCC-340K: A Faceted Hierarchical Dataset for Metadata Annotation in GLAM Collections

Archival strategies for contemporary collecting in a world of big data: Challenges and opportunities with curating the UK web archive

Join the Dots: assessing a collection of 80 million items at The Natural History Museum, London

A Workflow for GLAM Metadata Crosswalk

Elements for Constructing a Data Quality Policy to Aggregate Digital Cultural Collections: Cases of the Digital Public Library of America and Europeana Foundation

The Many Shapes of Archive-It

One small step? Collection strategies for libraries, archives, and museums in the space age

Visualizing a Large Spatiotemporal Collection of Historic Photography with a Generous Interface

Browsing Linked Open Data in Cultural Heritage: a shareable visual configuration approach

Michigan Shared Print Initiative and GreenGlass for Groups for Data Analysis in Developing a Collaborative Collective Collection

Valorization of Historical Natural History Collections Through Digitization: The Algarium Vatova–Schiffner