Computational Validation of a Mathematical Model of Stable Multi-Species Communities in a Hawk Dove Game

Jeffrey Lu

2023-04-03

Abstract:We revisit the original hawk-dove game with slight modifications to payoff values while maintaining the fundamental principles of interaction. The practical robustness of the theoretical tools of game theory is tested on a simulated population of hawks and doves with varying initial population distributions and peak growth rates. Additionally, we aim to find conditions in which the entire community fails or becomes a single-species population. The results show that the predicted community distribution is established by the majority of communities but fails to exist in communities with extreme initial imbalances in species distribution and insufficient growth rates. We also find that greater growth rates can compensate for more imbalanced initial conditions and that more balanced initial conditions can compensate for lower growth rates. Overall, the simple theoretical model is a strong predictor of the stable behavior of simulated multi-species communities.

Populations and Evolution,Computer Science and Game Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores a modified version of the Hawk-Dove game model and validates its effectiveness in predicting stable multi-species community distributions through computer simulations. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **Validate the effectiveness of the theoretical model**: The authors aim to verify whether a simple mathematical model (based on the Hawk-Dove game) can effectively predict the distribution of stable multi-species communities formed under different initial conditions and growth rates.

2. **Explore the conditions of failed communities**: In addition to validating the model's effectiveness, the authors also seek to identify the conditions that lead to the failure of the entire community or its transformation into a single species, known as "failed communities."

3. **Analyze the impact of extreme conditions**: The paper pays special attention to the impact of extremely unbalanced initial species distributions and insufficient growth rates on community stability.

By simulating communities composed of different initial proportions of hawks (representing aggressive species) and doves (representing non-aggressive species), as well as different maximum growth rates, the authors found that:

- In most cases, the community distributions predicted by the model closely matched the simulation results.
- When the initial species distribution was extremely unbalanced or the growth rate was too low, there was a significant deviation between the model's predicted distribution and the actual simulation results.
- Higher growth rates could compensate for more unbalanced initial conditions, while more balanced initial conditions could offset lower growth rates.

In summary, this study aims to validate the effectiveness of a simplified version of the Hawk-Dove game model in predicting stable multi-species community behavior through computer simulations and to explore the key factors affecting community stability.