A Comparative Study of National Cyber Security Strategies of ten nations

Adejoke T. Odebade,Elhadj Benkhelifa

2023-03-24

Abstract:This study compares the National Cybersecurity Strategies (NCSSs) of publicly available documents of ten nations across Europe (United Kingdom, France, Lithuania, Estonia, Spain, and Norway), Asia-Pacific (Singapore and Australia), and the American region (the United States of America and Canada). The study observed that there is not a unified understanding of the term "Cybersecurity"; however, a common trajectory of the NCSSs shows that the fight against cybercrime is a joint effort among various stakeholders, hence the need for strong international cooperation. Using a comparative structure and an NCSS framework, the research finds similarities in protecting critical assets, commitment to research and development, and improved national and international collaboration. The study finds that the lack of a unified underlying cybersecurity framework leads to a disparity in the structure and contents of the strategies. The strengths and weaknesses of the NCSSs from the research can benefit countries planning to develop or update their cybersecurity strategies. The study gives recommendations that strategy developers can consider when developing an NCSS.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to compare the National Cyber Security Strategies (NCSS) of 10 countries (the United Kingdom, France, Lithuania, Estonia, Spain, Norway, Singapore, Australia, the United States, and Canada). The main objectives of the study include:

1. **Comparing Different Countries' NCSS**:
- The study finds that the definitions of "cybersecurity" vary among countries, but a common point is that combating cybercrime requires multi-party cooperation, thus emphasizing the importance of international collaboration.

2. **Identifying Commonalities and Differences**:
- By comparing the structures and frameworks of NCSS, the study finds similarities in protecting critical assets, committing to research and development, and enhancing national and international cooperation.
- At the same time, the lack of a unified foundational cybersecurity framework leads to differences in strategy structure and content.

3. **Evaluating the Strengths and Weaknesses of NCSS**:
- By analyzing the NCSS of these countries, the study can provide valuable lessons for other countries in formulating or updating their cybersecurity strategies.

4. **Providing Recommendations**:
- The paper offers recommendations that can be referenced when formulating NCSS, to help policymakers better plan and develop cybersecurity strategies.

In summary, this paper aims to identify commonalities and differences through a comparative analysis of different countries' cybersecurity strategies and provide guidance and recommendations for the formulation of future cybersecurity strategies.