Modeling Migration-Induced Unemployment

Pascal Michaillat

2024-10-04

Abstract:Immigration is often blamed for increasing unemployment among local workers. However, standard models, such as the neoclassical model and the Diamond-Mortensen-Pissarides matching model, inherently assume that immigrants are absorbed into the labor market without affecting local unemployment. This paper presents a more general model of migration that allows for the possibility that not only the wages but also the unemployment rate of local workers may be affected by the arrival of newcomers. This extension is essential to capture the full range of potential impacts of labor migration on labor markets. The model blends a matching framework with job rationing. In it, the arrival of new workers can raise the unemployment rate among local workers, particularly in a depressed labor market where job opportunities are limited. On the positive side, in-migration helps firms fill vacancies more easily, boosting their profits. The overall impact of in-migration on local welfare varies with labor market conditions: in-migration reduces welfare when the labor market is inefficiently slack, but it enhances welfare when the labor market is inefficiently tight.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the impact of immigration on the unemployment rate in the local labor market. Specifically, standard economic models (such as the neoclassical model and the Diamond-Mortensen-Pissarides matching model) typically assume that immigration does not affect the unemployment rate of local workers but only impacts wages. However, real-world evidence suggests that immigration may increase the unemployment rate of local workers, especially in a sluggish labor market. Therefore, this paper proposes a more general model that allows immigration to affect not only wages but also the unemployment rate of local workers.

The main contributions of the paper are:
1. **Extending existing models**: By introducing a job rationing mechanism, the model can explain how immigration affects the tightness of the local labor market in the short term, thereby influencing the unemployment rate.
2. **Providing empirical support**: The paper cites multiple natural experiments and quasi-experimental studies, which consistently show that immigration does indeed increase the local unemployment rate.
3. **Explaining public concerns**: The model helps to understand why the public generally believes that immigrants "take away" their jobs, despite skepticism from the academic community.

Overall, this paper aims to fill the gap in existing economic models in explaining the impact of immigration on the unemployment rate and to provide a theoretical basis for designing more effective immigration policies.