Jackie Baek,Justin J. Boutilier,Vivek F. Farias,Jonas Oddur Jonasson,Erez Yoeli
Abstract:Behavioral health interventions, delivered through digital platforms, have the potential to significantly improve health outcomes, through education, motivation, reminders, and outreach. We study the problem of optimizing personalized interventions for patients to maximize a long-term outcome, where interventions are costly and capacity-constrained. We assume we have access to a historical dataset collected from an initial pilot study. We present a new approach for this problem that we dub DecompPI, which decomposes the state space for a system of patients to the individual level and then approximates one step of policy iteration. Implementing DecompPI simply consists of a prediction task using the dataset, alleviating the need for online experimentation. DecompPI is a generic model-free algorithm that can be used irrespective of the underlying patient behavior model. We derive theoretical guarantees on a simple, special case of the model that is representative of our problem setting. When the initial policy used to collect the data is randomized, we establish an approximation guarantee for DecompPI with respect to the improvement beyond a null policy that does not allocate interventions. We show that this guarantee is robust to estimation errors. We then conduct a rigorous empirical case study using real-world data from a mobile health platform for improving treatment adherence for tuberculosis. Using a validated simulation model, we demonstrate that DecompPI can provide the same efficacy as the status quo approach with approximately half the capacity of interventions. DecompPI is simple and easy to implement for an organization aiming to improve long-term behavior through targeted interventions, and this paper demonstrates its strong performance both theoretically and empirically, particularly in resource-limited settings.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to optimize personalized interventions to maximize long - term effects in behavioral health interventions, while considering the costs and resource limitations of the interventions. Specifically, the author focuses on behavioral health interventions provided through digital platforms (such as mobile applications), which aim to improve patients' health outcomes through education, motivation, reminders, and support. However, these interventions are usually accompanied by direct and indirect costs, and in the case of limited resources, the intervention subjects must be prioritized.
### Research Background and Problem Description
1. **High - cost interventions and the need for rational allocation**: For example, in the case of Keheala, patients need to self - verify on the mobile phone interface daily whether they take their medications on time. In addition, Keheala also provides a series of support measures, including automatic reminders, leaderboards, information push, and manual phone calls. Due to limited resources, the number of phone calls that support staff can make daily is far less than the number of patients in need of intervention.
2. **User compliance is a key indicator**: In many behavioral health applications, service providers (such as digital platforms) will collect user data to determine whether they are in the expected behavioral state (such as taking medications on time, exercising regularly, or following a correct diet). For Keheala, this key indicator is the daily self - verification rate.
3. **Limited initial data and heuristic - based rules**: When most digital behavioral health services are initially launched, they will use some simple heuristic rules to decide when to send intervention messages to users. These rules are usually binary eligibility criteria rather than an ordered ranking, so it is not possible to prioritize when the number of users exceeds the available resources.
### Core Problem
The core problem of the paper is: Can a practical priority strategy be designed using limited pilot study data (collected through some ad - hoc baseline strategy) to maximize the effectiveness of expensive interventions?
### Solution
To solve the above problems, the author proposes a new algorithm named DecompPI, which is implemented in the following ways:
- **Decomposition strategy iteration**: DecompPI decomposes the system state space to the individual patient level and approximately performs one policy iteration. Specifically, it predicts the q - value (i.e., state - action value) of each patient based on historical data, and then selects those patients with the largest increase in q - value after receiving the intervention for intervention at each time step.
- **No need for online experiments**: Unlike traditional reinforcement learning algorithms, DecompPI does not require online experiments or updates, but is fully optimized based on offline data.
- **Theoretical guarantee**: When the initial data collection strategy is random, DecompPI provides an improved theoretical guarantee compared to the null strategy of doing no intervention. In addition, this algorithm is robust to estimation errors.
### Experimental Verification
The author conducted a rigorous empirical study using real - data from mobile health platforms, demonstrating the effectiveness of DecompPI. The results show that in the case of limited resources, DecompPI can achieve the same efficacy as existing methods with approximately half of the intervention capacity. This indicates that DecompPI has significant advantages in resource - constrained environments, especially when promoted on a large scale.
### Summary
This paper proposes a novel algorithm, DecompPI, for optimizing personalized strategies in behavioral health interventions. By making full use of limited pilot data, DecompPI not only provides performance guarantees theoretically, but also performs well in practical applications, especially in the case of limited resources.