DEMNUni: The imprint of massive neutrinos on the cross-correlation between cosmic voids and CMB lensing

Pauline Vielzeuf,Matteo Calabrese,Carmelita Carbone,Giulio Fabbian,Carlo Baccigalupi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1475-7516/2023/08/010
2023-03-17
Abstract:Cosmic voids are a powerful probe of cosmology and are one of the core observables of upcoming galaxy surveys. The cross-correlations between voids and other large-scale structure tracers such as galaxy clustering and galaxy lensing have been shown to be very sensitive probes of cosmology and among the most promising to probe the nature of gravity and the neutrino mass. However, recent measurements of the void imprint on the lensed Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) have been shown to be in tension with expectations based on LCDM simulations, hinting to a possibility of non-standard cosmological signatures due to massive neutrinos. In this work we use the DEMNUni cosmological simulations with massive neutrino cosmologies to study the neutrino impact on voids selected in photometric surveys, e.g. via Luminous Red Galaxies, as well as on the void- CMB lensing cross-correlation. We show how the void properties observed in this way (size function, profiles) are affected by the presence of massive neutrinos compared to the neutrino massless case, and show how these can vary as a function of the selection method of the void sample. We comment on the possibility for massive neutrinos to be the source of the aforementioned tension. Finally, we identify the most promising setup to detect signatures of massive neutrinos in the voids-CMB lensing cross-correlation and define a new quantity useful to distinguish among different neutrino masses by comparing future observations against predictions from simulations including massive neutrinos.
Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper attempts to study the influence of neutrino mass on the cross - correlation between cosmic voids and the cosmic microwave background (CMB) lensing effect in cosmology. Specifically, the paper aims to: 1. **Explore the influence of neutrino mass on the properties of cosmic voids**: - Investigate how the size function and density profile of cosmic voids change in cosmological simulations that include neutrino mass. - Analyze how these properties change with different void sample selection methods. 2. **Evaluate whether neutrino mass can explain the observed tension between the CMB lensing effect and the standard ΛCDM model**: - Recent measurements show that the influence of cosmic voids on the CMB lensing effect is different from the simulation results based on the standard ΛCDM model, which may imply the existence of non - standard cosmological signals, such as neutrino mass. - By using DEMNUni cosmological simulations that include different neutrino masses, study whether these simulation results can explain the observed tension. 3. **Identify the settings most likely to detect the signature of neutrino mass**: - Define a new quantity to distinguish different neutrino masses and compare future observational results with simulation predictions that include neutrino mass. ### Background Cosmic voids are low - density regions in the large - scale structure of the universe, and they are of great value in cosmological research. The upcoming galaxy surveys (such as Euclid, DES, DESI and LSST) will map a large - scale picture of the recent universe with unprecedented precision and use these data to constrain cosmological models. In particular, the cross - correlation between cosmic voids and other large - scale structure tracers (such as galaxy clustering and galaxy lensing effect) is considered a powerful tool for probing the nature of gravity and neutrino mass. ### Methods The paper uses DEMNUni cosmological simulations, which consider cases with different neutrino masses. The main steps include: 1. **Construct the CMB lensing effect map**: - Use N - body simulation particle snapshots to construct a full - sky backward light cone and generate the CMB lensing effect map. - Implement high - resolution CMB lensing effect simulations in spherical coordinates through a multi - lens ray - tracing algorithm. 2. **Construct the cosmic void catalog**: - Use a 2D void finder to identify cosmic voids in the dark matter halo catalog of DEMNUni simulations. - By adjusting the smoothing parameter, study the properties of voids at different smoothing scales. 3. **Analyze the cross - correlation between cosmic voids and the CMB lensing effect**: - Measure the cross - correlation signal between cosmic voids and the CMB lensing effect in cases with different neutrino masses. - Compare the influence of different neutrino masses on the cross - correlation signal. ### Conclusions Through detailed simulations and analyses, the paper shows the influence of neutrino mass on the properties of cosmic voids and the cross - correlation of the CMB lensing effect. The research results are helpful for understanding the role of neutrino mass in cosmology and provide theoretical support for future observations.