A Bayesian theory of market impact

Louis Saddier,Matteo Marsili

2024-05-21

Abstract:The available liquidity at any time in financial markets falls largely short of the typical size of the orders that institutional investors would trade. In order to reduce the impact on prices due to the execution of large orders, traders in financial markets split large orders into a series of smaller ones, which are executed sequentially. The resulting sequence of trades is called a meta-order. Empirical studies have revealed a non-trivial set of statistical laws on how meta-orders affect prices, which include i) the square-root behaviour of the expected price variation with the total volume traded, ii) its crossover to a linear regime for small volumes, and iii) a reversion of average prices towards its initial value, after the sequence of trades is over. Here we recover this phenomenology within a minimal theoretical framework where the market sets prices by incorporating all information on the direction and speed of trade of the meta-order in a Bayesian manner. The simplicity of this derivation lends further support to the robustness and universality of market impact laws. In particular, it suggests that the square-root impact law originates from the over-estimation of order flows originating from meta-orders.

Trading and Market Microstructure,Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper attempts to solve the problem of theoretical explanation for the impact of large - scale trading orders (i.e., meta - orders) on prices in the financial market. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Rules of influence on market prices**:
- **Square - root behavior**: The relationship between the total trading volume \(Q\) of meta - orders and the price change \(\Delta p_T\) follows the square - root law, that is, \(E[\Delta p_T]\simeq\pm C\sigma_\tau\sqrt{\frac{Q}{V_\tau}}\), where \(\sigma_\tau\) and \(V_\tau\) are the price volatility and trading volume on the trading time scale \(\tau\), respectively.
- **Crossover to linear behavior**: For small trading volumes \(Q\), the relationship between price change and trading volume transitions from square - root behavior to linear behavior.
- **Price reversal**: After the execution of meta - orders is completed, the average price will gradually return to its initial value.

2. **Theoretical framework for market impact phenomena**:
- The author uses a simplified theoretical framework, based on the Glosten - Milgrom model (GMM), to explain how market prices are formed through Bayesian inference. In this framework, the market sets prices based on all information about the direction and speed of meta - orders.
- This model assumes that market participants (such as market makers) infer the frequency \(\nu\) of meta - orders through the Bayesian method and thus adjust prices.

3. **Consistency between theoretical predictions and empirical observations**:
- The paper aims to explain and predict the main features of market price impact phenomena through this simplified theoretical framework and provide verifiable predictions to further reveal the theoretical basis of market microstructure.

### Main contributions of the paper

1. **Simplicity of theoretical explanation**:
- Through the GMM model, the paper provides a parameter - free theoretical framework that can explain the main features of market price impact phenomena, including square - root behavior, crossover to linear behavior, and price reversal.

2. **Verifiability of predictions**:
- The paper proposes several verifiable predictions. For example, when the statistical average is conditioned on the start of meta - orders, the price volatility should increase by a constant term, and the average bid - ask spread should decrease with the square root of time \(t\).

3. **Consistency between theory and empirical evidence**:
- Through numerical simulation and theoretical analysis, the paper shows the consistency between model predictions and empirical observations, further supporting the universality and robustness of the market price impact law.

### Conclusion

In conclusion, this paper successfully explains the main phenomena of the impact of meta - orders on prices in the financial market through a simplified Bayesian theoretical framework. This theory not only provides an in - depth understanding of the market price impact law but also provides verifiable predictions for further empirical research.