Abstract:The logarithmic law of the wall, joining the inner, near-wall mean velocity profile (abbreviated MVP) in wall-bounded turbulent flows to the outer region, has been a permanent fixture of turbulence research for over hundred years, but there is still no general agreement on the value of the pre-factor, the inverse of the Kármán ``constant'' $\kappa$, or on its universality. The choice diagnostic tool to locate logarithmic parts of the MVP is to look for regions where the indicator function $\Xi$ (equal to the wall-normal coordinate $y^+$ times the mean velocity derivative $\dd U^+/\dd y^+$) is constant. In pressure driven flows however, such as channel and pipe flows, $\Xi$ is significantly affected by a term proportional to the wall-normal coordinate, of order $\mathcal{O}(\Reytau^{-1})$ in the inner expansion, but moving up across the overlap to the leading $\mathcal{O}(1)$ in the outer expansion. Here we show that, due to this linear overlap term, $\Reytau$'s well beyond $10^5$ are required to produce one decade of near constant $\Xi$ in channels and pipes. The problem is resolved by considering the common part of the inner asymptotic expansion carried to $\mathcal{O}(\Reytau^{-1})$, and the leading order of the outer expansion. This common part contains a \textit{superposition} of the log law and a linear term $S_0 \,y^+\Reytau^{-1}$, and corresponds to the linear part of $\Xi$, which, in channel and pipe, is concealed up to $y^+ \approx 500-1000$ by terms of the inner expansion. A new and robust method is devised to simultaneously determine $\kappa$ and $S_0$ in pressure driven flows at currently accessible $\Reytau$'s, yielding $\kappa$'s which are consistent with the $\kappa$'s deduced from the Reynolds number dependence of centerline velocities. A comparison with the zero-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layer further clarifies the issues.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the applicability and universality of the Logarithmic Law of the Wall (Log - Law for short) in wall - bounded turbulent flows (such as pipe and channel flows) in turbulence research. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to determine the pre - factor in the Log - Law - that is, the value of the von Kármán constant $ \kappa $ and its universality. The paper points out that although the Log - Law has existed in turbulence research for more than 100 years, there is still no general consensus on the value of $ \kappa $ and its universality to date. ### Main problems: 1. **Scope of application of the Log - Law**: The paper explores the scope of application of the Log - Law in wall - bounded turbulent flows, especially in pressure - driven flows (such as channel and pipe flows), whether the linear part of the Log - Law is affected by the wall - normal coordinate. 2. **Determination of the von Kármán constant $ \kappa $**: The paper proposes a new method to simultaneously determine $ \kappa $ and the linear term $ S_0 $ to solve the problem of the inconsistency of $ \kappa $ at currently achievable Reynolds numbers. 3. **Matching problem between the inner and outer layers**: The paper discusses the matching problem of the inner - and outer - layer asymptotic expansions, especially how to handle the contributions of the logarithmic term and the linear term in different layers. ### Specific problems: - **Influence of the linear overlapping term**: In pressure - driven flows, the indicator function $ \Xi $ of the Log - Law is affected by a linear term $ S_0 y^+ / Re_\tau $ proportional to the wall - normal coordinate. This linear term is a high - order term in the inner - layer expansion but a dominant term in the outer - layer expansion. The paper points out that due to the existence of this linear term, a very high Reynolds number is required to observe an approximately constant $ \Xi $ region in channels and pipes. - **Variability of data**: There is a large variability among different direct numerical simulation (DNS) results, which may be due to factors such as computational grid spacing, computational scheme, and convergence. By analyzing these variabilities, the paper proposes improved methods to determine $ \kappa $ and $ S_0 $. - **Verification of experimental data**: The paper uses experimental data (such as the data of Zanoun et al. (2003) and Schultz & Flack (2013)) to verify the theoretical analysis, especially to verify the superposition form of the Log - Law and the linear term. ### Solutions: - **New matching method**: The paper proposes a new method to simultaneously determine $ \kappa $ and $ S_0 $ by considering the common part of the inner - and outer - layer asymptotic expansions. This method is more robust and reliable at currently achievable Reynolds numbers. - **Comparison of experimental data**: By analyzing the experimental data, the paper verifies the correctness of the theoretical model and further clarifies the applicability of the Log - Law under different flow conditions. In summary, this paper aims to solve the problems of the applicability and universality of the Log - Law in wall - bounded turbulent flows through theoretical analysis and experimental verification, especially how to accurately determine the von Kármán constant $ \kappa $ at currently achievable Reynolds numbers.

The hunt for the Kármán "constant'' revisited

On the difficulty of determining Kármán “constants” from direct numerical simulations

On the difficulty of determining Karman 'constants' from DNS

Karman Constant and Accurate Mean Flow Prediction in a Turbulent Pipe

Quantifying wall turbulence via a symmetry approach. Part 2. Reynolds stresses

Reynolds number scaling and inner-outer overlap of stream-wise Reynolds stress in wall turbulence

On the Karman constant in turbulent channel flow

Reynolds number asymptotics of wall-turbulence fluctuations

Structure and interpolation of the turbulent velocity profile in parallel flow

Predictions of Canonical Wall-Bounded Turbulent Flows Via a Modified K–ω Equation

Logarithmic distribution of mean velocity and turbulent kinetic energy in a pipe flow

Direct Numerical Simulation and Theory of a Wall-Bounded Flow with Zero Skin Friction

The universality of the law of the wall: A long-lasting controversial debate

Law of Bounded Dissipation and Its Consequences in Turbulent Wall Flows

Origin of High Kurtosis Levels in the Viscous Sublayer : Direct Numerical Simulation and Experiment

On the Kármán momentum-integral approach and the Pohlhausen paradox

Searching for the log law in open channel flow

Reynolds number required to accurately discriminate between proposed trends of skin friction and normal stress in wall turbulence

Asymptotics of stream-wise Reynolds stress in wall turbulence

Self-scaling generalized Townsend-Perry constants for high-order moments in turbulent boundary layers

On the streamwise velocity variance in the near-wall region of turbulent flows