Changes in mobility choices during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic: a comparison between Italy and Sweden

Daniele Giubergia,Elisa Bin,Marco Diana

2023-03-14

Abstract:The spread of COVID-19 disease affected people's lives worldwide, particularly their travel behaviours and how they performed daily activities. During the first wave of the pandemic, spring 2020, countries adopted different strategies to contain the spread of the virus. The aim of this paper is to analyse the changes in mobility behaviours, focusing on the sustainability level of modal choices caused by the pandemic in two countries with different containment policies in place: Italy and Sweden. Survey data uncovered which transport means was the most used for three different trip purposes (grocery shopping, non-grocery shopping and commuting) both before and during the first wave of the pandemic. The variation in the sustainability level of modal choices was then observed through descriptive statistics and significance tests. By estimating three multinomial logistic regression models, one for each trip purpose, we tried to identify which factors, beyond the country, affected the variation in the sustainability level of the modal choice with the beginning of the pandemic. Results show a greater reduction in mobility among the Italian sample compared to the Swedish one, especially for public transit, and a major inclination by Swedes in travelling by foot and by bike compared to Italians, also due to the greater possibility of making trips during the first wave of the pandemic. Finally, perceived safety on public transit seems to have no significant effects on the variation in the sustainability level of the modal choice with the beginning of restrictions. Our results can be used as a starting point for a discussion on how the COVID-19 pandemic affected attitudes and preferences towards the different travel alternatives. Also, in this work we highlighted how people reacted in different ways to an unprecedented situation in two Countries with opposite containment strategies in place.

Physics and Society,Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how people's choices of travel modes changed during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in Italy and Sweden, two countries that adopted different control policies, and particularly how these changes impacted the environmental sustainability levels of travel modes.

Specifically, the study collected data through a questionnaire survey and compared the changes in the most commonly used transportation modes for three common travel purposes (grocery shopping, non-food shopping, and commuting) before and after the pandemic in the two countries. The study found:

1. **Commuting**: Before the pandemic, Swedes used public transportation more for commuting, while Italians relied more on private transportation. During the pandemic, the proportion of public transportation use in Italy significantly dropped to 3%, and in Sweden, it decreased from 46% to 8%, but Swedes increased the proportion of walking or cycling.

2. **Grocery Shopping**: Before the pandemic, Italians were more inclined to use private transportation for grocery shopping, while Swedes also mainly used private transportation but had a higher proportion of public transportation use. During the pandemic, the proportion of private transportation use in Italy decreased from 79% to 67%, and in Sweden, it decreased from 53% to 51%, but both countries had more "not applicable" responses, possibly because many people stopped going out for shopping.

3. **Non-Food Shopping**: Before the pandemic, Swedes were more inclined to use public transportation for non-food shopping, but this proportion significantly dropped to 9% during the pandemic; in contrast, the public transportation usage rate for Italians decreased from 12% to 1%. Similarly, Italy had a large number of "not applicable" responses, indicating that many people stopped shopping for non-essential items.

Additionally, the study analyzed the changes in the environmental sustainability of travel modes. The results showed:

- The sustainability of commuting travel modes for Italians decreased from 24% before the pandemic to 16%.
- The sustainability of commuting travel modes for Swedes also decreased, but from 69% to 58%, still maintaining a high level.
- In terms of grocery shopping, the proportion of Italians using sustainable transportation modes actually increased by 8%.
- For non-food shopping, the proportion of Swedes shifting from sustainable to unsustainable transportation modes increased by 9%.

Through multiple logistic regression analysis, the study found that living in Sweden compared to Italy was more likely to maintain the use of sustainable transportation modes rather than switching to private transportation. Additionally, households without children were more likely to maintain or switch to using sustainable transportation modes.

In summary, this paper aims to explore how the COVID-19 pandemic affected people's choices of different travel modes and particularly focuses on the impact of these changes on the environmental sustainability of travel modes.