Testing Gravity on Cosmological Scales: Theoretical Predictions with the COLA Method

Bartolomeo Fiorini

2023-03-10

Abstract:One of the main objectives of stage IV galaxy surveys is to constrain gravity on cosmological scales. To this end, it is crucial to make accurate theoretical predictions in the nonlinear regime of structure formation in order to maximise the scientific return. This is possible at a relatively low computational cost thanks to COLA simulations, an approximate and much faster alternative to full $N$-body simulations. In this thesis, we focus on two modified gravity theories, $f(R)$ and nDGP, and present an analysis of how COLA simulations can be combined with empirical models for the galaxy-halo connection to produce realistic mock galaxy catalogues in modified gravity. We then use the resulting galaxy catalogues to study the effects of modified gravity and validate COLA simulations for several probes of the large-scale structure like the galaxy power spectrum, bispectrum and the void-galaxy cross-correlation function. Finally, we propose the COLA method for the extension of cosmological emulators to modified gravity theories and showcase its potential by training an emulator for the nDGP boost factor of the matter power spectrum, i.e., the ratio of the power spectrum in nDGP gravity with that in general relativity.

Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem this paper attempts to address is testing gravity theories on cosmological scales, particularly Modified Gravity (MG) theories. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to make accurate theoretical predictions for MG theories during the nonlinear structure formation stage, in order to better utilize data from Stage IV galaxy surveys to constrain these theories.

### Main Research Content:
1. **Background of Modified Gravity Theories**:
- The standard cosmological model (based on General Relativity) requires a dark energy component to explain the late-time accelerated expansion of the universe, but dark energy lacks a solid theoretical foundation in the Standard Model of particle physics.
- Modified Gravity theories provide an alternative explanation by introducing additional scalar fields to explain the phenomenon of accelerated expansion.

2. **Theoretical Predictions for the Nonlinear Structure Formation Stage**:
- During the nonlinear structure formation stage, the effects of Modified Gravity theories are more significant, thus requiring accurate theoretical predictions.
- N-body simulations can generate synthetic galaxy catalogs, but the computational cost is very high, especially under Modified Gravity theories.

3. **Application of the COLA Method**:
- The COLA (COmoving Lagrangian Acceleration) method is an approximate simulation method that can generate synthetic galaxy catalogs at a lower computational cost.
- The paper extends the COLA method to be applicable to Modified Gravity theories and verifies its accuracy in generating synthetic galaxy catalogs.

4. **Specific Research Objects**:
- The focus is on two Modified Gravity theories: f(R) and nDGP (normal branch of the Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati model).
- By comparing the statistics generated by the COLA method with full N-body simulation results, the paper verifies the ability of the COLA method to capture Modified Gravity effects in redshift space.

5. **Further Applications**:
- Using the generated synthetic galaxy catalogs, the paper studies the impact of Modified Gravity on large-scale structure probes (such as power spectrum, bispectrum, and voids).
- The paper explores the possibility of extending cosmological simulators using COLA simulation results, particularly under Modified Gravity theories.

### Main Conclusions:
- The COLA method can accurately capture the effects of Modified Gravity on galaxy clustering, especially in redshift space.
- By comparing different large-scale structure probes, the paper verifies the effectiveness of the COLA method during the nonlinear structure formation stage.
- The paper proposes methods to extend cosmological simulators using COLA simulation results, providing new tools and directions for future research.

Overall, this paper aims to improve the ability to constrain Modified Gravity theories on cosmological scales through improved simulation methods, thereby providing new perspectives for understanding the accelerated expansion of the universe.