Differential voltage analysis for battery manufacturing process control

Andrew Weng,Jason B. Siegel,Anna Stefanopoulou

2023-03-13

Abstract:Voltage-based battery metrics are ubiquitous and essential in battery manufacturing diagnostics. They enable electrochemical "fingerprinting" of batteries at the end of the manufacturing line and are naturally scalable, since voltage data is already collected as part of the formation process which is the last step in battery manufacturing. Yet, despite their prevalence, interpretations of voltage-based metrics are often ambiguous and require expert judgment. In this work, we present a method for collecting and analyzing full cell near-equilibrium voltage curves for end-of-line manufacturing process control. The method builds on existing literature on differential voltage analysis (DVA or dV/dQ) by expanding the method formalism through the lens of reproducibility, interpretability, and automation. Our model revisions introduce several new derived metrics relevant to manufacturing process control, including lithium consumed during formation and the practical negative-to-positive ratio, which complement standard metrics such as positive and negative electrode capacities. To facilitate method reproducibility, we reformulate the model to account for the "inaccessible lithium problem" which quantifies the numerical differences between modeled versus true values for electrode capacities and stoichiometries. We finally outline key data collection considerations, including C-rate and charging direction for both full cell and half cell datasets, which may impact method reproducibility. This work highlights the opportunities for leveraging voltage-based electrochemical metrics for online battery manufacturing process control.

Systems and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

The paper primarily explores how to improve quality control in the battery manufacturing process using voltage analysis methods. Specifically, the paper collects and analyzes near-equilibrium voltage curve data at the end of the manufacturing process through Differential Voltage Analysis (DVA or dV/dQ) to achieve control over the manufacturing process.

#### Main Objectives:
1. **Propose a repeatable and easy-to-interpret method**: By extending the existing DVA method to make it more repeatable and automated, thereby enhancing its application value in manufacturing process control.
2. **Develop new derivative indicators**: Introduce new electrochemical indicators, such as the amount of lithium consumed during formation and the actual negative-to-positive ratio (NPR), which can complement standard indicators like electrode capacity.
3. **Address the "unreachable lithium problem"**: Redefine the model to address the "unreachable lithium problem," i.e., the discrepancy between model values and actual values.
4. **Identify key data collection factors**: Clarify the key data collection factors that affect the repeatability of the method, including C-rate and charging direction.
5. **Provide opportunities for online battery manufacturing process control**: Demonstrate the potential for using voltage-based electrochemical indicators for online battery manufacturing process control.

### Summary

Voltage-based battery indicators are common and important in battery manufacturing diagnostics, allowing for electrochemical "fingerprinting" of batteries on the production line. However, despite their widespread presence, their interpretation is often ambiguous and requires expert judgment. The paper proposes a method for collecting and analyzing near-equilibrium voltage curves of full cells at the end of the manufacturing process and extends this method by improving its repeatability, interpretability, and automation. Additionally, several derivative indicators related to manufacturing process control are introduced, and the "unreachable lithium problem" is addressed to promote method repeatability. Finally, the paper identifies key data collection considerations affecting method repeatability, such as C-rate and charging direction. This work emphasizes the opportunity for using voltage-based electrochemical indicators for online battery manufacturing process control.