Small amplitude red giants elucidate the nature of the Tip of the Red Giant Branch as a standard candle

Richard I. Anderson,Nolan W. Koblischke,Laurent Eyer

2024-03-04

Abstract:The tip of the red giant branch (TRGB) is an important standard candle for determining luminosity distances. Although several $10^5$ small amplitude red giant stars (SARGs) have been discovered, variability was previously considered irrelevant for the TRGB as a standard candle. Here, we show that all stars near the TRGB are SARGs that follow several period-luminosity sequences, of which sequence A is younger than sequence B as predicted by stellar evolution. We measure apparent TRGB magnitudes, m$_{\mathrm{TRGB}}$, in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), using Sobel filters applied to photometry from the Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment and the ESA Gaia mission, and we identify several weaknesses in a recent LMC-based TRGB calibration used to measure the Hubble constant. We consider four samples: all Red Giants (RGs), SARGs, and sequences A & B. The B-sequence is best suited for measuring distances to old RG populations, with M$_{\mathrm{F814W,0}}$ = -4.025 $\pm$ 0.014(stat.) $\pm$ 0.033(syst.) mag assuming the LMC's geometric distance. Control of systematics is demonstrated using detailed simulations. Population diversity affects m$_{\mathrm{TRGB}}$ at a level exceeding the stated precision: the SARG and A-sequence samples yield 0.039 mag and 0.085 mag fainter (at 5{\sigma} significance) m$_{\mathrm{TRGB}}$ values, respectively. Ensuring equivalent RG populations is crucial to measuring accurate TRGB distances. Additionally, luminosity function smoothing ($\sim$ 0.02 mag) and edge detection response weighting (as much as -0.06 mag) can further bias TRGB measurements, with the latter introducing a tip-contrast relation. We are optimistic that variable red giants will enable further improvements to the TRGB as a standard candle.

Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,Astrophysics of Galaxies,Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the accuracy of the tip of the red - giant - branch (TRGB) as a standard candle in distance measurement. Specifically, the authors explored the variability of small - amplitude red giants (SARGs) near the TRGB and attempted to improve the TRGB distance - measurement method through these variabilities. The following are the key points of the paper:

1. **Importance of TRGB**:
- TRGB is one of the important standard candles used to determine the distances of galaxies, especially when measuring the Hubble constant (\(H_0\)).

2. **Discovery of SARGs**:
- The paper points out that almost all stars close to the TRGB are SARGs. These stars follow multiple period - luminosity sequences, among which sequence A is younger than sequence B, which is consistent with the predictions of stellar evolution.

3. **TRGB measurement in the LMC**:
- The authors used photometric data from the Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment (OGLE) and the ESA Gaia mission and applied the Sobel filter to measure the apparent TRGB magnitude (\(m_{\text{TRGB}}\)) in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC).
- They identified some weaknesses in the recently LMC - based TRGB calibrations, which were used to measure the Hubble constant.

4. **Comparison of different samples**:
- The study considered four samples: all red giants (RGs), SARGs, and sequences A and B. Among them, sequence B is the most suitable for measuring the distances of old RG populations, with an absolute magnitude \(M_{F814W,0}=- 4.025\pm0.014 (\text{statistical})\pm0.033 (\text{system})\) magnitudes.

5. **Control of systematic errors**:
- Through detailed simulations, the control of systematic errors was demonstrated. The influence of population diversity on \(m_{\text{TRGB}}\) exceeds the declared accuracy: the SARG and sequence A samples respectively make the \(m_{\text{TRGB}}\) value fainter by 0.039 magnitudes and 0.085 magnitudes (at the 5 - σ significance level).

6. **Other biasing factors**:
- Photometric - function smoothing (about 0.02 magnitudes) and edge - detection - response weighting (up to - 0.06 magnitudes) can further bias the TRGB measurement, and the latter introduces a tip - contrast relationship.

7. **Conclusions and prospects**:
- The authors are optimistic that reddening red giants will further improve the performance of TRGB as a standard candle.

In conclusion, through a detailed analysis of the variability of SARGs, this paper proposes a new method to improve TRGB distance measurement, which is of great significance for improving the accuracy of cosmological parameter measurement.