Amr Osman,Jorge Fernàndez-Pendàs,Christopher Warren,Sandoko Kosen,Marco Scigliuzzo,Anton Frisk Kockum,Giovanna Tancredi,Anita Fadavi Roudsari,Jonas Bylander
Abstract:The reproducibility of qubit parameters is a challenge for scaling up superconducting quantum processors. Signal crosstalk imposes constraints on the frequency separation between neighboring qubits. The frequency uncertainty of transmon qubits arising from the fabrication process is attributed to deviations in the Josephson junction area, tunnel barrier thickness, and the qubit capacitor. We decrease the sensitivity to these variations by fabricating larger Josephson junctions and reduce the wafer-level standard deviation in resistance down to 2%. We characterize 32 identical transmon qubits and demonstrate the reproducibility of the qubit frequencies with a 40 MHz standard deviation (i.e. 1%) with qubit quality factors exceeding 2 million. We perform two-level-system (TLS) spectroscopy and observe no significant increase in the number of TLSs causing qubit relaxation. We further show by simulation that for our parametric-gate architecture, and accounting only for errors caused by the uncertainty of the qubit frequency, we can scale up to 100 qubits with an average of only 3 collisions between quantum-gate transition frequencies, assuming 2% crosstalk and 99.9% target gate fidelity.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the qubit - frequency - collision problem in superconducting quantum processors as the number of qubits increases. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:
1. **Reproducibility of qubit parameters**: When expanding the scale of superconducting quantum processors, signal crosstalk imposes limitations on the frequency separation between adjacent qubits. Due to deviations in the manufacturing process, especially changes in Josephson - junction area, tunnel - barrier thickness, and qubit capacitance, the qubit frequency becomes uncertain.
2. **Reducing frequency uncertainty**: By fabricating larger Josephson junctions to reduce sensitivity to these changes and reducing the standard deviation of wafer - level resistors to 2%. The authors characterized 32 identical transmons qubits, demonstrating the reproducibility of qubit frequencies with a standard deviation of 40 MHz (i.e., 1%) and a qubit quality factor exceeding 2 million.
3. **Influence of two - level systems (TLS)**: Through simulation, it was studied that in a parametric - gate architecture, considering only the uncertainty of qubit frequencies, it can be extended to 100 qubits with an average of only 3 collisions between qubit - gate transition frequencies, assuming 2% signal crosstalk and 99.9% target - gate fidelity.
### Main content overview
1. **Introduction**:
- The paper introduced the physical and engineering challenges faced when expanding the scale of quantum processors, including qubit decoherence, circuit integration, and signal wiring.
- It particularly emphasized the reproducibility problem of qubit frequencies in fixed - frequency qubit architectures. For example, the cross - resonance - gate architecture requires the standard deviation of qubit frequencies to be less than 6 MHz in order to be extended to 1,000 qubits.
2. **Fabrication of Josephson junctions and room - temperature - resistance characterization**:
- By optimizing the manufacturing process, larger Josephson junctions were fabricated, and resistance changes were compensated by increasing the tunnel - barrier thickness.
- The resistances of thousands of Josephson junctions at room temperature were measured and compared with the low - temperature characterization results.
3. **Characterization of qubit - frequency changes**:
- 32 fixed - frequency transmons qubits were fabricated and their transition frequencies were measured. The results showed that the standard deviation of qubit frequencies was 40 MHz (1%), which was consistent with expectations.
- Through analysis, it was found that changes in qubit capacitance also significantly contributed to changes in qubit frequencies.
4. **Qubit coherence and TLS spectroscopy**:
- The influence of strongly - coupled TLS in Josephson junctions on qubit coherence was studied.
- Through TLS spectroscopy experiments, it was found that larger Josephson junctions did not significantly increase the number of strongly - coupled TLS.
5. **Frequency collisions in quantum processors**:
- Through Monte Carlo simulation, the influence of qubit - frequency changes on frequency collisions in quantum processors based on parametric - gate architectures was studied.
- The results showed that with a standard deviation of 40 MHz, the number of frequency collisions in a 100 - qubit system was reduced by a factor of three. However, in order to obtain high - yield collision - free chips and high - fidelity gate operations, the frequency change needs to be further reduced to about 15 MHz.
### Conclusion
The paper demonstrated that by fabricating Josephson junctions with larger areas, the frequency reproducibility of fixed - frequency transmons qubits can be significantly improved, with the standard deviation reduced to 40 MHz. This provides important technical support for expanding the scale of quantum processors. However, in order to achieve high - yield collision - free chips and high - fidelity gate operations, the manufacturing process still needs to be further optimized to reduce the frequency change to about 15 MHz. In addition, signal crosstalk can also be minimized by improving wiring, grounding, and shielding.