Financing Costs, Per-Shipment Costs and Shipping Frequency: Firm-Level Evidence from Bangladesh

Md Deluair Hossen

2023-03-08

Abstract:In international trade, firms face lengthy ordering-producing-delivery times and make shipping frequency decisions based on the per-shipment costs and financing costs. In this paper, I develop a model of importer-exporter procurement where the importer procures international inputs from exporting firms in developing countries. The exporters are credit constrained for working capital, incur the per-shipment fixed costs, and get paid after goods are delivered to the importer. The model shows that the shipping frequency increases for high financing costs in origin and destination. Furthermore, longer delivery times increase shipping frequency as well as procurement costs. The model also shows that the higher per-shipment fixed costs reduce the shipping frequency, in line with previous literature. Reduced transaction costs lower the exporter's demand for financial services through shipping frequency adjustment, mitigating the financial frictions of the firm. Then, I empirically investigate whether the conclusions regarding the effect of per-shipment fixed costs on shipping frequency from the theoretical model and in the existing literature extend to developing countries. My estimation method addresses several biases. First, I deal with aggregation bias with the firm, product, and country-level analysis. Second, I consider the Poisson Pseudo Maximum Likelihood (PPML) estimation method to deal with heteroscedasticity bias from the OLS estimation of log-linear models. Third, I fix the distance non-linearity of Bangladeshi exports. Finally, I consider the effect of financing cost on shipping frequency to address omitted variable bias. Using transaction-level export data from Bangladesh, I find that 10% higher per-shipment costs reduce the shipping frequency by 3.45%. The findings are robust to different specifications and subsamples.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the issue of how firms in international trade balance financing costs and fixed costs per shipment to determine the optimal shipping frequency. Specifically, the author analyzes how the shipping frequency is affected by financing costs, delivery time, and fixed costs per shipment when importers procure international inputs from exporters in developing countries by establishing a theoretical model. Additionally, the author conducts an empirical study using transaction-level export data from Bangladesh to verify whether these theoretical conclusions apply to developing countries.

### Main Issues:
1. **Impact of Financing Costs on Shipping Frequency**: High financing costs increase shipping frequency because exporters need to ship more frequently to reduce the time funds are tied up.
2. **Impact of Delivery Time on Shipping Frequency**: Longer delivery times increase shipping frequency because it raises procurement costs.
3. **Impact of Fixed Costs per Shipment on Shipping Frequency**: Higher fixed costs per shipment reduce shipping frequency because each shipment becomes more expensive.
4. **Specificity of Developing Countries**: The author explores whether these theoretical conclusions apply to developing countries, particularly Bangladesh.

### Research Background:
- **Time Lags in International Trade**: The long order, production, and delivery times in international trade pose a challenge for suppliers, especially those in developing countries.
- **Financing Constraints**: Firms in developing countries often face financing constraints and need to borrow to cover production and other costs.
- **Limitations of Existing Literature**: Existing research mainly focuses on developed countries, while the situation in developing countries may differ.

### Research Methods:
- **Theoretical Model**: The author establishes a theoretical model that combines the effects of financing costs and fixed costs per shipment to analyze the determinants of shipping frequency.
- **Empirical Analysis**: Using transaction-level export data from Bangladesh from 2006 to 2013, the author employs the Poisson Pseudo Maximum Likelihood (PPML) method to estimate and address issues such as heteroscedasticity and omitted variable bias.

### Main Findings:
- **Impact of Financing Costs and Delivery Time on Shipping Frequency**: High financing costs and longer delivery times increase shipping frequency.
- **Impact of Fixed Costs per Shipment on Shipping Frequency**: Higher fixed costs per shipment reduce shipping frequency.
- **Specificity of Developing Countries**: For Bangladesh, a 10% increase in fixed costs per shipment results in a 3.45% decrease in shipping frequency, a significantly higher impact than in developed countries.

### Significance of Empirical Results:
- **Policy Recommendations**: Reducing fixed costs per shipment can significantly reduce the financing needs of firms in developing countries, thereby alleviating financial constraints.
- **Trade Facilitation**: Reducing transaction costs and financing needs in developing countries helps improve the efficiency of international trade.

Through this research, the author provides new perspectives on understanding the behavior of developing countries in international trade and offers valuable references for policymakers.