Abstract:Kitaev materials are a promising platform for the realization of quantum spin liquid states. The thermal Hall effect has emerged as a potential probe of exotic excitations within such states. In the Kitaev candidate material $\alpha$-RuCl$_{3}$, however, the thermal Hall conductivity $\kappa_{xy}$ has been attributed not only to exotic Majorana fermions or chiral magnons, but also to phonons. It has been shown theoretically that the former two types of heat carriers can generate a "planar" thermal Hall effect, whereby the magnetic field is parallel to the heat current, as observed experimentally, but it is unknown whether phonons also could. Here we show that a planar thermal Hall effect is present in another Kitaev candidate material, Na$_{2}$Co$_{2}$TeO$_{6}$. On the basis of a striking similarity between the temperature and field dependence of $\kappa_{xy}$ and that of the phonon-dominated thermal conductivity $\kappa_{xx}$, we argue that the planar thermal Hall effect in Na$_{2}$Co$_{2}$TeO$_{6}$ is generated by phonons. The phonon contributed planar $\kappa_{xy}$ also shows a strong sample dependence, which indicates an extrinsic origin of the mechanism. By conducting a complete study with different in-plane configurations of heat current $J$ and magnetic field $H$, $i.e.$ $H$ $\|$ $J$ and $H$ $\bot$ $J$, we observe a large difference in $\kappa_{xy}$ between these two configurations, which reveals that the direction of the heat current $J$ may play an important role in determining the planar thermal Hall effect. Our observation calls for a re-evaluation of the planar thermal Hall effect observed in $\alpha$-RuCl$_{3}$.

Phononic-magnetic dichotomy of the thermal Hall effect in the Kitaev-Heisenberg candidate material Na$_2$Co$_2$TeO$_6$

Phononic-magnetic Dichotomy of the Thermal Hall Effect in the Kitaev Material Na_{2}Co_{2}TeO_{6}

Phonon thermal transport shaped by strong spin-phonon scattering in a Kitaev material Na$_2$Co$_2$TeO$_6$

Phonon Thermal Transport Shaped by Strong Spin-Phonon Scattering in a Kitaev Material Na_2Co_2TeO_6

Planar thermal Hall effect from phonons in a Kitaev candidate material

Unusual heat transport of the Kitaev material Na$_2$Co$_2$TeO$_6$: putative quantum spin liquid and low-energy spin excitations

Majorana-fermion origin of the planar thermal Hall effect in the Kitaev magnet $α$-RuCl$_3$

Thermal Transport of Fractionalized Antiferromagnetic and Field Induced States in the Kitaev Material Na_2Co_2TeO_6

Strongly scattered phonon heat transport of the candidate Kitaev material Na<sub>2</sub>Co<sub>2</sub>TeO<sub>6</sub>

Majorana-fermion origin of the planar thermal Hall effect in the Kitaev magnet α-RuCl 3

Magnon-polaron driven thermal Hall effect in a Heisenberg-Kitaev antiferromagnet

Quantized and unquantized thermal Hall conductance of Kitaev spin-liquid candidate $α$-RuCl$_3$

Significant Thermal Hall Effect in the 3d Cobalt Kitaev System Na2Co2TeO6

Non-Majorana Origin of the Half-Quantized Conductance Plateau in Quantum Anomalous Hall Insulator and Superconductor Hybrid Structures

Anisotropic in-plane heat transport of Kitaev magnet Na$_2$Co$_2$TeO$_6$

Field-Angle-Resolved Specific Heat in Na$_2$Co$_2$TeO$_6$: Evidence against Kitaev Quantum Spin Liquid

Static magnetic order with strong quantum fluctuations in spin-1/2 honeycomb magnet Na2Co2TeO6

Magnetic Ground State of the Kitaev Na_{2}Co_{2}TeO_{6} Spin Liquid Candidate

Anisotropy of thermal conductivity oscillations in relation to the Kitaev spin liquid phase

Emergent quantum disordered phase in Na$_2$Co$_2$TeO$_6$ under intermediate magnetic field along $c$ axis