Abstract:With the forthcoming release of high precision polarization measurements, such as from the Planck satellite, it becomes critical to evaluate the performance of estimators for the polarization fraction and angle. These two physical quantities suffer from a well-known bias in the presence of measurement noise, as has been described in part I of this series. In this paper, part II of the series, we explore the extent to which various estimators may correct the bias. Traditional frequentist estimators of the polarization fraction are compared with two recent estimators: one inspired by a Bayesian analysis and a second following an asymptotic method. We investigate the sensitivity of these estimators to the asymmetry of the covariance matrix which may vary over large datasets. We present for the first time a comparison among polarization angle estimators, and evaluate the statistical bias on the angle that appears when the covariance matrix exhibits effective ellipticity. We also address the question of the accuracy of the polarization fraction and angle uncertainty estimators. The methods linked to the credible intervals and to the variance estimates are tested against the robust confidence interval method. From this pool of estimators, we build recipes adapted to different use-cases: build a mask, compute large maps, and deal with low S/N data. More generally, we show that the traditional estimators suffer from discontinuous distributions at low S/N, while the asymptotic and Bayesian methods do not. Attention is given to the shape of the output distribution of the estimators, and is compared with a Gaussian. In this regard, the new asymptotic method presents the best performance, while the Bayesian output distribution is shown to be strongly asymmetric with a sharp cut at low S/N.Finally, we present an optimization of the estimator derived from the Bayesian analysis using adapted priors.

Improper statistics of the radiation from a randomly rotating source

Polarization measurements analysis I. Impact of the full covariance matrix on polarization fraction and angle measurements

Electromagnetic random source for circular optical frame and its statistical properties

Polarization measurements analysis II. Best estimators of polarization fraction and angle

Rotational Anomaly for the Chern–Simons Vortices

Stokes parameters and degree of polarization of nonparaxial stochastic electromagnetic beams

Optical Möbius strips in isotropic random non-paraxial light

Sokolov--Ternov effect in rotating systems

Optical momentum distributions in monochromatic, isotropic random vector fields

The influence of rotation in radiation driven winds from hot stars II. CAK topological analysis

Spin of Photons: Nature of Polarisation

Quantum field theory for coherent photons: isomorphism between stokes parameters and spin expectation values

An Examination of Polarization Mode Transitions in Pulsar Radio Emission

Statistics of the individual-pulse polarization based on propagation effects in pulsar magnetosphere

Studies of regular and random magnetic fields in the ISM: statistics of polarization vectors and the Chandrasekhar-Fermi technique

Changes in the statistical properties of stochastic anisotropic electromagnetic beams on propagation in the turbulent atmosphere.

Randomness of optical turbulence generated by Rayleigh-Bénard convection using intensity statistics

The Stokes Vector Measurement

Quantum radiation reaction: Analytical approximations and obtaining the spectrum from moments