Dispersed, condensed and self-limiting states of geometrically frustrated assembly

Nicholas W. Hackney,Christopher Amey,Gregory M. Grason

2023-08-06

Abstract:In self-assembling systems, geometric frustration leads to complex states characterized by internal gradients of shape misfit. Frustrated assemblies have drawn recent interest due to the unique possibility that their thermodynamics can sense and select the finite size of assembly at length scales much larger than constituent building blocks or their interactions. At present, self-limitation is chiefly understood to derive from zero-temperature considerations, specifically the competition between cohesion and scale-dependent elastic costs of frustration. While effects of entropy and finite temperature fluctuations are necessarily significant for self-assembling systems, their impact on the self-limiting states of frustrated assemblies is not known. We introduce a generic, minimal model of frustrated assembly, and establish its finite-temperature and concentration dependent thermodynamics by way of simulation and continuum theory. The phase diagram is marked by three distinct states of translation order: a dispersed vapor; a defect-riddled condensate; and the self-limiting aggregate state. We show that, at finite temperature, the self-limiting state is stable at intermediate frustration. Further, in contrast to the prevailing picture, its thermodynamic boundaries with the macroscopic disperse and bulk states are temperature controlled, pointing to the essential importance of translational and conformational entropy in their formation.

Soft Condensed Matter,Materials Science,Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the influence of finite temperature and concentration on the Self - Limiting Aggregation (SLA) state in geometrically frustrated self - assembling systems. Specifically, the authors introduced a minimized geometrically frustrated self - assembling model and established its thermodynamic properties at finite temperature through simulation and continuum theory. The research mainly focuses on three different translational order states: the dispersed vapor state, the condensed state with many defects, and the self - limiting aggregation state. The key problem of the paper is to explore whether the self - limiting aggregation state is stable under moderate frustration conditions at finite temperature, and how the thermodynamic boundaries between it and the macroscopic dispersed and bulk states are controlled by temperature. This indicates that translational and conformational entropy play a crucial role in the formation of these states.

### Main problems
1. **Stability of the self - limiting aggregation state**: Is the self - limiting aggregation state stable under moderate geometric frustration conditions at finite temperature?
2. **Temperature dependence of the thermodynamic boundary**: How is the thermodynamic boundary between the self - limiting aggregation state and the macroscopic dispersed and bulk states affected by temperature?
3. **Role of entropy**: What role do translational and conformational entropy play in the formation of the self - limiting aggregation state?

### Research methods
- **Model introduction**: The authors introduced a two - dimensional lattice model to describe the geometric frustration of the self - assembling system. The model contains two key components: the translational degrees of freedom of subunits and the energy cost of "shape mismatch".
- **Thermodynamic analysis**: The thermodynamic behavior of the model under different temperature and concentration conditions was studied through Monte Carlo simulation and continuum theory.
- **Phase diagram**: Three different translational order states were determined: the dispersed vapor state, the condensed state with many defects, and the self - limiting aggregation state.

### Key findings
- **Stability of the self - limiting aggregation state**: Under moderate geometric frustration conditions, the self - limiting aggregation state is stable at finite temperature.
- **Temperature dependence of the thermodynamic boundary**: The thermodynamic boundary between the self - limiting aggregation state and the macroscopic dispersed and bulk states is controlled by temperature.
- **Role of entropy**: Translational and conformational entropy play a decisive role in the formation of the self - limiting aggregation state. In particular, in the equilibrium state, the competition between entropy effects and elastic gradients determines the final state of the system.

### Formulas
- **Lattice Hamiltonian**:
\[
H = -J \sum_{\langle ij \rangle} \cos(\Delta \theta_{ij} - A_{ij}) \eta_i \eta_j - K \sum_{\langle ij \rangle} \eta_i \eta_j
\]
where \(\Delta \theta_{ij}=\theta_i - \theta_j\) is the phase difference between \(i\) and \(j\), \(A_{ij}\) is the gauge field defined on the lattice bond, \(\eta_i\) is the occupation number (0 or 1), and \(J\) and \(K\) are the direction - dependent binding energy and non - specific binding energy, respectively.

- **Elastic energy density**:
\[
E[D]=\frac{J}{2} \int_D d^2x\left|\nabla \theta - A(x)\right|^2+\Sigma P[D]-\epsilon_{\text{bulk}} A[D]
\]
where \(\Sigma\) and \(\epsilon_{\text{bulk}}\) are the surface energy and bulk energy, respectively, and \(P[D]\) and \(A[D]\) are the perimeter and area of the domain, respectively.

- **Self - limiting aggregation size**:
\[
W^*\approx\ell_d\equiv\left(\frac{\Sigma}{J f^2}\right)^{1/3}
\]
where \(\ell_d\) is the characteristic domain scale and \(f\) is the frustration intensity.

Through these studies, the authors revealed the complex behavior of geometrically frustrated self - assembling systems at finite temperature and provided a new perspective for understanding the self - limiting aggregation phenomenon.