Internal gravity waves in stratified flows with and without vortical modes

Vincent Labarre,Pierre Augier,Giorgio Krstulovic,Sergey Nazarenko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.9.024604

2023-11-02

Abstract:The comprehension of stratified flows is important for geophysical and astrophysical applications. The Weak Wave Turbulence theory aims to provide a statistical description of internal gravity waves propagating in the bulk of such flows. However, internal gravity waves are usually perturbed by other structures present in stratified flow, namely the shear modes and the vortical modes. In order to check whether a weak internal gravity wave turbulence regime can occur, we perform direct numerical simulations of stratified turbulence without shear modes, and with or without vortical modes at various Froude and buoyancy Reynolds numbers. We observe that removing vortical modes naturally helps to have a better overall balance between poloidal kinetic energy, involved in internal gravity waves, and potential energy. However, conversion between kinetic energy and potential energy does not necessarily show fluctuations around zero in our simulations, as we would expect for a system of weak waves. A spatiotemporal analysis reveals that removing vortical modes helps to concentrate the energy around the wave frequency, but it is not enough to observe a weak wave turbulence regime. Yet, we observe that internal gravity waves whose frequency are large compared to the eddy turnover time are present, and we also find evidences for slow internal gravity waves interacting by Triadic Resonance Instabilities in our strongly stratified flows simulations. Finally, we propose conditions that should be fulfilled in order to observe a weak internal gravity waves turbulence regime in real flows.

Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore whether the phenomenon of Weak Internal Gravity Wave Turbulence (WIGWT) exists in stratified flows and analyze whether this phenomenon can be observed under different conditions. Specifically, the author studied the behavior of stratified turbulence with or without vortical modes through Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS), especially under different Froude number ($F_h$) and buoyancy Reynolds number ($R$) conditions when the shear modes were removed.

### Main research questions
1. **Existence of Weak Internal Gravity Wave Turbulence**:
- The paper attempts to verify whether the phenomenon of Weak Internal Gravity Wave Turbulence exists in stratified flows. Weak Internal Gravity Wave Turbulence refers to the situation where the nonlinear interactions are weak and the statistical properties of the waves can be described by the Weak Wave Turbulence (WWT) theory.

2. **Effect of Removing Vortical Modes**:
- The author studied the effect of removing vortical modes on the dynamics of stratified flows, especially on the wave energy spectrum and the energy conversion process. Vortical modes are usually related to vertical vorticity and may interfere with the propagation and interaction of internal gravity waves.

3. **Observation under Parameter Conditions**:
- The paper explored whether the phenomenon of Weak Internal Gravity Wave Turbulence can be observed under different Froude numbers and buoyancy Reynolds numbers. These parameters reflect the dynamic characteristics of the fluid, such as the stratification intensity and the degree of turbulence.

### Research methods
- **Numerical simulation**: Use the 3D Navier - Stokes equations for numerical simulation under the Boussinesq approximation to simulate the dynamic processes in stratified flows.
- **Parameter setting**: Different Brunt - Väisälä frequencies ($N$) and viscosity coefficients ($\nu$) were considered in the simulation, and the fluid behavior under different conditions was studied by controlling the input buoyancy Reynolds number ($R_i$).
- **Removing specific modes**: The shear modes and vortical modes were removed by the method of projection in the spectral space to study the influence of these modes on internal gravity waves.

### Main findings
- **Energy distribution**: After removing the vortical modes, the energy distribution in the stratified flow is more balanced, especially the balance between wave energy and potential energy.
- **Energy conversion**: Removing the vortical modes helps to concentrate energy near the wave frequency, but it is not sufficient to observe the typical weak wave turbulence phenomenon.
- **Wave - frequency characteristics**: In strongly stratified flows, internal gravity waves with higher frequencies were observed, as well as low - frequency internal gravity waves interacting through Triadic Resonance Instabilities.
- **Condition suggestions**: The conditions required to observe the phenomenon of Weak Internal Gravity Wave Turbulence in real fluids were proposed, including appropriate stratification intensity and degree of turbulence.

In conclusion, through detailed numerical simulation and analysis, this paper explored the existence and conditions of the Weak Internal Gravity Wave Turbulence phenomenon in stratified flows, providing important theoretical and experimental bases for understanding stratified flows in geophysics and astrophysics.