That's All Folks: a KG of Values as Commonsense Social Norms and Behaviors

Stefano De Giorgis,Aldo Gangemi

2023-03-02

Abstract:Values, as intended in ethics, determine the shape and validity of moral and social norms, grounding our everyday individual and community behavior on commonsense knowledge. Formalising latent moral content in human interaction is an appealing perspective that would enable a deeper understanding of both social dynamics and individual cognitive and behavioral dimension. To tackle this problem, several theoretical frameworks offer different values models, and organize them into different taxonomies. The problem of the most used theories is that they adopt a cultural-independent perspective while many entities that are considered "values" are grounded in commonsense knowledge and expressed in everyday life interaction. We propose here two ontological modules, FOLK, an ontology for values intended in their broad sense, and That's All Folks, a module for lexical and factual folk value triggers, whose purpose is to complement the main theories, providing a method for identifying the values that are not contemplated by the major value theories, but which nonetheless play a key role in daily human interactions, and shape social structures, cultural biases, and personal beliefs. The resource is tested via performing automatic detection of values from text with a frame-based approach.

Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence,Symbolic Computation

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve

The main problem this paper attempts to address is the limitation of existing theories of moral and social values in describing specific behavioral norms in everyday life. Specifically:

1. **Limitations of Existing Theories**:
- Existing theories of moral values (such as Basic Human Values [BHV] and Moral Foundations Theory [MFT]) tend to describe high-level concepts and seek to establish a cross-cultural universal model.
- These theories often overlook specific values in daily life that play a crucial role in everyday interactions.

2. **Proposed New Approach**:
- The authors propose two new ontology modules: FOLK and That’s All Folks (TAF), aimed at complementing the existing major theories.
- These modules provide a bottom-up approach to identifying and describing values that are not covered by the major theories but still play an important role in daily life, starting from a list of common values collected from the web.

3. **Specific Goals**:
- Provide a method to identify values that are not included in the major value theories but play a crucial role in daily interactions.
- By formally describing these values, enable the detection and reasoning of these culturally dependent entities, such as "health," "punctuality," "wealth," etc.

4. **Experimental Validation**:
- The authors validate the resources by automatically detecting values in texts and demonstrate that this method significantly improves the understanding of potential moral content.
- Experimental results show that a large number of everyday values can be detected in sentences that were originally thought to have no explicit moral content.

In summary, this paper aims to address the shortcomings of existing theories in describing specific behavioral norms in everyday life by introducing new ontology modules, thereby better understanding and analyzing social dynamics and individual behavior.