Universal mechanism of Ising superconductivity in twisted bilayer, trilayer and quadrilayer graphene

J. Gonzalez,T. Stauber
2023-03-01
Abstract:We show that the superconducivity in twisted graphene multilayers originates from a common feature, which is the strong valley symmetry breaking characteristic of these moiré systems at the magic angle. This leads to a breakdown of the rotational symmetry of the flat moiré bands down to $C_3$, and to ground states in which the time-reversal symmetry is broken for a given spin projection. However, this symmetry can be recovered upon exchange of spin-up and spin-down electrons, as we illustrate by means of a self-consistent microscopic Hartree-Fock resolution where the states for the two spin projections acquire opposite sign of the valley polarization. There is then a spin-valley locking by which the Fermi lines for the two spin projections are different and related by inversion symmetry. This effect represents a large renormalization of the bare spin-orbit coupling of the graphene multilayers, lending protection to the superconductivity against in-plane magnetic fields. In the twisted bilayer as well as in trilayer and quadrilayer graphene, the pairing glue is shown to be given by the nesting between parallel segments of the Fermi lines which arise from the breakdown of symmetry down to $C_3$. This leads to a strong Kohn-Luttinger pairing instability, which is relevant until the Fermi line recovers gradually a more isotropic shape towards the bottom of the second valence band, explaining why the superconductivity fades away beyond three-hole doping of the moiré unit cell.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the question of what the universal mechanism of superconductivity (SC) is in twisted multilayer graphene (including bilayer, trilayer, and tetralayer). Specifically, the authors explore whether the superconducting phenomena observed in these materials near the magic angle share a common physical mechanism and how this mechanism leads to superconductivity. ### Main Research Content: 1. **Valley Symmetry Breaking (VSB)**: - The authors found that the superconductivity in these twisted multilayer graphene systems near the magic angle originates from a common feature, namely strong valley symmetry breaking. This breaking reduces the rotational symmetry of the quasi-flat bands from \(C_6\) to \(C_3\). - This symmetry breaking also leads to time-reversal symmetry breaking, but this symmetry can be restored when exchanging spin-up and spin-down electrons. 2. **Spin-Valley Locking**: - Strong valley symmetry breaking results in different Fermi lines for the two spin projections, and they are related by inversion symmetry in reciprocal space. - This effect significantly enhances the spin-orbit coupling in the graphene multilayer structures, thereby protecting superconductivity from in-plane magnetic fields. 3. **Coulomb Interaction and Pairing Mechanism**: - Using the Hartree-Fock approximation, the authors studied the impact of Coulomb interactions on the symmetry breaking modes of these systems. - They found that Coulomb interactions lead to strong distortions of the Fermi lines, generating a negative (attractive) coupling on the Fermi lines, which triggers Kohn-Luttinger (KL) pairing instability. - This instability explains why superconductivity gradually disappears when more than 3 holes are doped. ### Conclusion: - The authors propose that the superconductivity in twisted bilayer, trilayer, and tetralayer graphene originates from strong valley symmetry breaking, which leads to asymmetric distribution of the Fermi lines and spin-valley locking. - This mechanism not only explains the superconductivity in these systems but also accounts for the experimentally observed stability of superconductivity under high in-plane magnetic fields and the violation of the Pauli limit. Through these studies, the authors provide a unified theoretical framework for understanding superconductivity in twisted multilayer graphene.