Abstract:This is the first in a series of papers where we study the dynamics of a bubble wall beyond usual approximations, such as the assumptions of spherical bubbles and infinitely thin walls. In this paper, we consider a vacuum phase transition. Thus, we describe a bubble as a configuration of a scalar field whose equation of motion depends only on the effective potential. The thin-wall approximation allows obtaining both an effective equation of motion for the wall position and a simplified equation for the field profile inside the wall. Several different assumptions are involved in this approximation. We discuss the conditions for the validity of each of them. In particular, the minima of the effective potential must have approximately the same energy, and we discuss the correct implementation of this approximation. We consider different improvements to the basic thin-wall approximation, such as an iterative method for finding the wall profile and a perturbative calculation in powers of the wall width. We calculate the leading-order corrections. Besides, we derive an equation of motion for the wall without any assumptions about its shape. We present a suitable method to describe arbitrarily deformed walls from the spherical shape. We consider concrete examples and compare our approximations with numerical solutions. In subsequent papers, we shall consider higher-order finite-width corrections, and we shall take into account the presence of the fluid.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the dynamical description of bubble walls during the cosmic phase transition, especially when the bubble walls are not idealized thin - walled or spherical. Specifically, the authors focus on the behavior of bubble walls in vacuum phase transitions, which involves a more accurate description of the motion of the bubble - wall equation, going beyond the traditional thin - wall approximation. Traditional methods usually assume that bubbles are perfectly spherical and that the bubble walls are very thin, but these assumptions may not hold in certain cases, such as in strong first - order phase transitions or when the bubble walls develop strong spatial curvature due to instability. ### Main contributions of the paper: 1. **Analysis of the assumptions of the thin - wall approximation**: The paper discusses in detail the various assumptions of the thin - wall approximation and their applicable conditions, especially regarding the magnitude of the effective potential difference \(\Delta V\) and the importance of four - dimensional curvature. 2. **Improved thin - wall approximation**: Several improved methods are proposed, such as an iterative method to solve the wall profile and perturbation calculations based on the wall width. 3. **Equation for arbitrarily deformed bubble walls**: A general equation that does not depend on the shape of the bubble wall is derived, which is suitable for describing bubble walls from spherical to arbitrarily deformed. 4. **Comparison of specific examples with numerical solutions**: The effectiveness of the proposed approximation methods is verified through specific examples and compared with numerical solutions. ### Mathematical expressions: - The effective equation of the bubble wall can be expressed as: \[ \phi''(n)-K(n)\phi'(n) = V'(\phi) \] where \(K(n)\) is the mean curvature and \(n\) is the coordinate perpendicular to the hypersurface. - The mean curvature \(K\) can be calculated by the following formula: \[ \phi = -\frac{1}{2}\bar{g}_{ab}\partial_n\bar{g}_{ab} \] - The surface tension \(\sigma\) is obtained by integrating the square of the field gradient: \[ \sigma=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}\phi'(n)^2\,dn \] - The wall equation can be written as: \[ -\sigma K_{ab}\gamma^{ab}=\Delta V \] where \(\Delta V = V_+ - V_-\) is the energy difference between the two potential minima. ### Conclusion: Through these improvements and new derivations, the paper provides a more general and accurate framework for describing the dynamics of bubble walls, especially in cases where the bubble walls are thick or have irregular shapes. This is of great significance for understanding physical phenomena in the cosmic phase - transition process, such as the generation of gravitational waves.

Thin and thick bubble walls I: vacuum phase transitions

Thin and thick bubble walls II: expansion in the wall width

Numerical Investigation on the Collapse of a Bubble Cluster Near a Solid Wall

Bubble wall velocities in the Standard Model and beyond

Bubble dynamics at the electroweak scale

Field-theoretic derivation of bubble-wall force

Bounds on the bubble wall velocity

General bubble expansion at strong coupling

Thermalization effects on the dynamics of growing vacuum bubbles

On the dynamics of a collapsing bubble in contact with a rigid wall

Bubble wall velocity from number density current in (non)equilibrium

Vacuum bubble collisions: from microphysics to gravitational waves

Bubble-wall speed with loop corrections

Instanton Model of QCD Phase Transition Bubble Walls

Bubbles in liquids with phase transition

Hydrodynamical constraints on bubble wall velocity

Bubble wall velocities with an extended fluid Ansatz

The hydrodynamics of inverse phase transitions

Bubble wall velocity beyond leading-log approximation in electroweak phase transition